edit very first line from http://www.tumblr.com/about
"Tumblr lets you effortlessly share anything."
which is a bold faced lie.
It takes about 5 seconds to find import generic drugs spam on tumbler. http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/generic-drugs Reimporting drugs is out and out illegal, but they don't seem to be cracking down on that.
Personally, I'm really torn. Perhaps being vocal on tumbler will encourage friends to help self mutilators get help. Perhaps the act of public expression is really damaging. Without a lot more information, i'm ok with tumblr doing whatever they feel is best.
The thing i hate is the out and out hypocrisy. Share anything. To me, that means: this is a free and open place. be who you are, tell the world.
I'm not picking out some random line in some pr statement. This is the first line of the about page. This is content that should be vetted, that really matches the company's values.
I am all for free speech, but there is a long list of things like child porn, state secrets, copyrighted material, etc that I think we would all agree is not in Tumblr's best interest to not be shared effortlessly.
Libel laws for example, limit our free speech. Another definition of rights is set out in the UDHR, article 5 states:
No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
The case can be made that promoting eating disorders and other forms of self harm is a cruel and degrading way to treat your fellow humans. Even if the perpetrator believes themselves to be acting in everybody's best interests.
(I know this isn't a reply to your actual argument, but I don't have the authority to delete epistemically dangerous posts, so I figured posting this was more appropriate than trying to get myself set up as a censor. :-) )
(Also, is there a commonly agreed-upon way of putting a :-) emoticon at the end of a parenthesized region? The apparent paren mismatch bothers me.)
Is it cruel to find a gay kid's tumblr and tell him to kill himself? What if I simply say gay teen should kill themselves? How about that they're sinners and are going to hell? What about simply saying that I think marriage is between one man and one woman? Where does untasteful become cruel enough to ban?
Tumblr is free to do whatever they want. Users are free to ditch Tumblr because "self-injury" isn't defined and Tumblr gets to be the sole decider of what is or isn't allowed based on their arbitrary rulings.
(Hm, downvoted for pointing out that the only person here who brought up free speech... is someone who preemptively and unnecessarily argued against using free speech as an argument. Literally, no one here is saying Tumblr is required to allow this for free speech reasons.)
Freedom of speech does not apply when you participate on a private organization's platform.
For those that strongly oppose these types of policies from social networks, I'm very much in favor of you starting your own social network to cater to tastes and generes that suit what you feel is appropriate for your community.