Re:Tumblr’s banning “self-harm” blogs that promote eating di...
by BadCookie on Thursday February 23, 2012 @07:19PM
(#3627382)
How do you feel about someone livecasting their own suicide, then, to take your position to an extreme?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tumblr’s banning “self-harm” blogs that promote eating di...
by tweak2live on Thursday February 23, 2012 @07:28PM
(#3627411)
I feel like censoring it would be unethical, while refusing to host it would simply be poor form.
Livecasting of own suicide: freedom of expression + freedom to make choices with regard to own life.
Edit: This is not to imply that Tumblr is not entitled to do whatever they damn please with their own website. But, should someone build a website specifically for livecasting suicides I would very much disagree with its censorship.
Re:Tumblr’s banning “self-harm” blogs that promote eating di...
by pjscott on Thursday February 23, 2012 @08:19PM
(#3627540)
I consider suicide extremely sad, and would not feel particularly inclined to watch the video. Why are we even thinking about censorship in this hypothetical scenario? What good would censoring the video do?
Put a warning on it saying that it's NSFL, maybe run a free banner ad next to it for a suicide prevention hotline. Those things are reasonable, productive responses. Censorship of the video would be as symbolic as waving a flag, and about as useful.
Re:Tumblr’s banning “self-harm” blogs that promote eating di...
by BadCookie on Friday February 24, 2012 @11:54AM
(#3629825)
It is not just a hypothetical. See http://news.cnet.com/report-teen-commits-suicide-on-justin-t...
Censoring the video may actually have prevented the suicide, because viewers were egging him on. It's hard to know.
Re:Tumblr’s banning “self-harm” blogs that promote eating di...
by jQueryIsAwesome on Thursday February 23, 2012 @07:23PM
(#3627390)
Promoting suicide ≠ snuff films