Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by sctb on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:40PM
(#36266318)
Since you mention Advaita, some mind find this talk by Swami Sarvapriyananda on "Vedantic Self and Buddhist Non-Self" interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAZPWu084m4.
Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by atlantic on Friday June 09, 2023 @08:56PM
(#36266428)
The conventional academic opinion is that Buddhism was wiped out in India by the Muslim invasions in the 8th century, not by scholarly debate.
Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by jimsimmons on Saturday June 10, 2023 @12:21AM
(#36267574)
Muslims didn’t come till 11th century
Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by atlantic on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:12AM
(#36271204)
Interesting. Wikipedia says Muslim invasions started in 712 AD, "with increasing frequency". I guess they got it wrong.
Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by jimsimmons on Saturday June 10, 2023 @12:31PM
(#36271948)
They didn’t establish a kingdom. And they didn’t affect most of India.
Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by atlantic on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @12:23PM
(#36328282)
If your contention is that buddhism was wiped out of India by academic debates with Hindus, it's not borne out by the facts. Certainly, the shift in royal patronage from Buddhism to Hinduism was also a factor, not only the Muslim invasions. But philosophical debate was not the root cause - nothing is ever resolved in philosophy anyway, and if it were, that would hardly impact lay practitioners.
Re:Eastern philosophy says there is no “self.” Science agrees
by rramadass on Saturday June 10, 2023 @11:25PM
(#36277694)
The English word "Self" used in Advaita translations (and all Hindu philosophies and their derivatives like Buddhism) and Western Philosophy mean very different things.
In Western Philosophy they are synonymous with "Self-Identity/Ego" etc.
In Hindu philosophy, the basic idea of "Self" comes from the "Samkhya System" (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samkhya) which is what is followed by/built upon by other schools of Hindu Philosophy. In this model, "Self" aka "Purusha" is immutable and untainted/undifferentiated pure Consciousness. In Advaita it is known as "Atman". It is "Prakriti", the other aspect of reality which is mutable, that gives rise to "Buddhi"(Intelligence), "Ahamkara"(Self-Identity/Ego) and "Manas"(Mind).
You can see now how confusion arises when people use the same English word "Self" to describe different things in different contexts.
Buddhism which was dominant among the elites and aristocrats by 8th century was largely displaced out of India via scholarly debates.
This idea that east doesn’t believe in self is hokum