Re:Microsoft DeviceScript – TypeScript for Tiny IoT Devices
by ivxvm on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:28AM
(#36259300)
Idk, I think it's extremely statistically rare coincidence for nominative typing to be a better default than structural. In other words, it's much more useful (by default) to have some function work on more types than be a little bit more type-safe for the exactly the type author had in mind when writing it. In my opinion, type-safety has diminishing returns and the most of its usefulness lies in trivial things, like passing a string instead of some object or array just as a typo, or writing a wrong field name when mapping one object to another, but nominative typing lies way beyond my imaginary line marking the zone when types become more of annoyance than help.
There's obviously other cases of ergonomic benefit to structural typing (including that idiomatic JS duck-typing patterns work as you'd hope), but I think its not unreasonable for someone to feel that it's their biggest problem with typescript (as grandparent OP did).