News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Synthesis Tutor – Your child’s own superhuman math tutor by musicale on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:13PM (#36250622)
> A computer can’t display more digits than the number of particles in the observable universe. This is a finite number. As such it is correct to say that computers struggle if the number of digits is too large

There are two sources of confusion here:

1. Your interpretation is essentially "computers struggle to complete tasks that are impossible for them to complete" - a meaningless tautology. At best it is "nothing scales infinitely" which perhaps is a bit more useful as a refutation for complaints that something "doesn't scale" in an unlimited fashion.

2. The meaning of "too" is ambiguous in English. You are using it in the sense of "above a limit" but (especially for a third grader) "too" also means "very". In the second sense, it is clear that computers readily handle numbers with huge numbers of digits - enough to represent any practical physical quantity, or any level of precision that can be practically measured.

Re:Synthesis Tutor – Your child’s own superhuman math tutor by symic on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:16PM (#36251285)
I think you don’t tech professionally.
Re:Synthesis Tutor – Your child’s own superhuman math tutor by musicale on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:30PM (#36251416)
> I think you don’t tech professionally.

I don't know whether you mean "teach" or "tech" here, but this seems to be an ad hominem argument.

Regardless, I would submit that clarity and correctness matter both in teaching and in tech.

Re:Synthesis Tutor – Your child’s own superhuman math tutor by symic on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:41PM (#36251531)
It’s not an ad hominem. It’s a polite way to suggest that you don’t know what you are talking about when it comes to teaching concepts to kids. I think it’s worth your while to wonder why it is so obvious that you are not a teacher. What experience and insights regarding age appropriate explanations are you missing that make it so obvious that you don’t teach?

Correctness, of the sort you are implying are absolutely not appropriate at all levels. There’s a reason kids in second grade are told that you can’t subtract a larger number from a smaller one, for instance.

Re:Synthesis Tutor – Your child’s own superhuman math tutor by musicale on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:57PM (#36251701)
1. I'm puzzled that you can't see why it's an ad hominem argument and seem to be leaning into that further.

2. In grades 1-2 (iirc) we used negative numbers when we talked about the number line (which we had on the wall.) Preschoolers already knew about negative temperatures on the thermometer.

3. See PP's original comment.

Re:Synthesis Tutor – Your child’s own superhuman math tutor by light_hue_1 on Thursday June 22, 2023 @10:02AM (#36432334)
I teach professionally.

You don't need to tell kids things that are misleading nonsense. It only confuses them more. You can be precise and high level at the same time.

In no sense do computers struggle with digits. That's a misleading confusing statement and it's not appropriate at any age.