News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by haswell on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:24PM (#36244507)
I think that more than anything, the inclusion of this feature is a hint about where Apple intends to take this product, and that they want to send a crystal clear message that this device is meant for interacting with other people.

And it seems this is such an important aspect of the product that they're willing to reduce the addressable market from a cost perspective.

This, to me, is what makes this product intriguing. And it makes me think that Apple's real goal is something closer to a pair of glasses, and they just know they can't get there without a long series of iterations.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by JohnFen on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:39PM (#36244713)
> that they want to send a crystal clear message that this device is meant for interacting with other people.

But that display increases the "creepy factor" by orders of magnitude.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by haswell on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:46PM (#36244850)
This product isn't in the public's hands yet, so I think it's a bit early to conclude that it's categorically creepy.

But even if it ends up being a bit creepy, a) I think Apple is well aware of that and b) again I think this highlights how important they think it is to send the message from day 1 that solving for isolation is a top priority and intrinsic to their end-goal.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by JohnFen on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:49PM (#36244918)
> This product isn't in the public's hands yet, so I think it's a bit early to conclude that it's categorically creepy

I was just going by the materials that Apple has released. It's true that I haven't personally seen the device in action in real life. But what Apple has shown certainly triggers a "creepy factor" in me.

Whether or not this is an issue for many people, and whether or not Apple will address it, isn't really relevant. What I've seen right now creeps me out a bit.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by haswell on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:22PM (#36247262)
> Whether or not this is an issue for many people, and whether or not Apple will address it, isn't really relevant

Why/how is this not relevant in a broader sense?

Or are you just saying this isn’t relevant to you personally?

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by JohnFen on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:47PM (#36250310)
Yes, to me, personally. I should have made that more clear. Sorry.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by haswell on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:44PM (#36250982)
Makes more sense and thanks for clarifying.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by fullspectrumdev on Thursday June 08, 2023 @03:51PM (#36247778)
Pretty much everyone I have spoken to about the thing has been like “that’s fucking creepy”.

A few have hoped you can display something else on it - like cat eyes or something to make it less fucking weird.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by ricardobeat on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:43PM (#36250969)
Face filters in video were considered extremely creepy 3 years ago.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by acomjean on Thursday June 08, 2023 @04:44PM (#36248691)
When google glass came out, there was the question of if you want to talk to someone who has a camera running at all times, (recording?). Its weird how perspective shifts.

Of course in some places if its recording all the time it might be in some weird wire taping situation.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by omegaworks on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:26PM (#36250094)
Google is also in the market of using every bit of data it can possibly record of you to show you ads.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by smoldesu on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:52PM (#36250374)
It's a shame I don't trust Apple not to do the same anymore. If the advertisement creep into MacOS is any indication, the Vision Pro might have more pop-ups than the Quest.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by JohnFen on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:48PM (#36250323)
> Its weird how perspective shifts.

It's not clear that it has shifted yet. It wasn't clear that Google Glass would be rejected until people started wearing them publicly.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by saurik on Thursday June 08, 2023 @07:07PM (#36250548)
Huh. To me it massively decreases the "creepy factor", as the idea that someone is watching me when I can't see their eyes looking at me is where the creepiness originates... the only thing we normally interact with where that happens with people are mirrored sunglasses, and those are themselves often associated with cops and (if you even consider this a separate category ;P) creeps.
Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by deanCommie on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:08PM (#36251201)
At least you KNOW they're not interacting with you.

With the exterior glass projection you THINK you're making eye contact with them, while both of you are looking at screens through cameras.

dystopian!

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by haswell on Friday June 09, 2023 @10:37AM (#36258474)
This scenario seems functionally similar to a FaceTime call or other form of video communication. Both parties know they’re not literally gazing into each other’s eyes, but the technical medium creates a pretty decent long distance approximation of doing just that.

A video call will never replace the real thing, but I don’t think I’d say it’s dystopian.

And I don’t find the tech in this headset all that different, the exception being that there isn’t a 2nd set of cameras and screens on the non-headset side of the conversation.

On the other hand, maybe it is dystopian, but if so, I’d argue that dystopia is already here and has been for awhile.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by JohnFen on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:26AM (#36259261)
> This scenario seems functionally similar to a FaceTime call or other form of video communication.

But in a video call, the "distance" the video causes is something that you put up with in exchange for a greater benefit. If I'm talking with someone that has a screen in front of their face showing me their face, that's distance that provides no benefit, so it's a loss without gain. It makes the person seem sketchy.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by deanCommie on Friday June 09, 2023 @12:32PM (#36260319)
I don't know what kind of Facetime calls you're having but 99% of the time I'm looking at someone's face, but we're not making eye contact.

The video is almost never exactly where the camera is, and if the person is using an external camera or a secondary monitor, the eyeline will never line up.

It's fine! But you never have the illusion that you're talking to the person directly. Which may be is good enough for adults working on professional projects.

But it's not good enough for a parent interacting with a young child.

Re:The paper that came up with Apple Vision Pro's outward-fa... by JohnFen on Friday June 09, 2023 @11:23AM (#36259221)
But you still can't see their eyes. You're seeing an image on a screen. That strikes my creepy nerve because it seems even more opaque than if they are wearing sunglasses or something. Rather than just being aware that their eyes are being hidden, it feels like an attempt is being made to actively deceive me.

It's the same sort of creepy I get when someone is wearing a realistic mask.