News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:07AM (#36240500)
The smugness and naivety in that article is grating, though not unexpected from the Guardian.

How nice to live in the perfect situation of no young kids, close transport and services and no need for frequent longer commutes away from transport.

Then the casual comment that his wife will "just use taxis."

I have a feeling he could afford the £250

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:16AM (#36240611)
No kids? Author clearly mentions he had a young daughter that had just out grown their child seat when they gave up their car.

Certainly living in city with good public transport is a large factor. By why can’t we build more places like that, and making living car free easy and practical for everyone? It’s ultimately cheaper and healthier for both the individuals and society as a whole, why hate on those that want see more people being able to benefit from such a lifestyle?

As for taxis, in London, the money you save on fuel, tax, congestion charges, maintenance, insurance etc etc which all come with car ownership, will pay for a lot of taxi rides each year.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by rootusrootus on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:37AM (#36240869)
> why hate on those that want see more people being able to benefit from such a lifestyle?

You are experiencing pushback because not everyone agrees with your assertion that

> It's ultimately cheaper and healthier for both the individuals and society as a whole

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:56AM (#36241102)
There’s quite a lot of data to backup that assertion. It’s not like nobody has bothered to study it.

It’s also kind of self evident. How can forcing everyone to buy, maintain and drag around 2 tons of machinery everywhere ever be cheaper and more efficient than using the legs you already have? Obviously there are those that physically need mechanical assistance to move around, but they’re the minority, we can accommodate them without forcing mechanical dependency on everyone.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:32AM (#36241587)
Walk 10km to work and back each day to actually get paid and see how that efficiency works out for you. It's like everyone lives in inner cities but are just busy being lazy.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:07AM (#36243104)
Why does everyone have to live 100km from work? Why would we want to force everyone to live a 100km from their work, why not let people live close to their work and make that pleasant and comfortable?

There are more ways to live that in single family homes in suburbs miles from everything you need to live (like work, food and entertainment). Why not live near all stuff you need for life? Wouldn’t that be much cheaper, more efficient, easier and generally just nicer?

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:53PM (#36252902)
Because corporations and worksites centralise to where transit and distribution is most efficient.

Plus, real estate costs aren't exactly flat everywhere.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Saturday June 10, 2023 @08:08AM (#36269801)
You know that in many parts of the world, living near your work and your shops is normal right?

Only in the U.S. is such an arrangement unusual, and where living miles from everything is normal. The U.S. is like this by choice, US zoning laws make any other way of living practically illegal. The U.S. could choose to do something different, or at least give people the freedom to try something different. It is meant to be the land of the free, and the free market after all.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Saturday June 10, 2023 @09:54AM (#36270483)
And in many parts of the world it's not. I think our increased mobility in recent times has also added distance to everything, but that's not the point I'm making above.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:18AM (#36240627)
Sorry, yes meant to say young kids. Though I suppose that doesn't matter, there are ways to carry, cart them around.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:20AM (#36240660)
The fatality rate for cycling in an urban area is much higher than that of driving. I’m not sure I’d be comfortable with a young child on a bike.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:31AM (#36240787)
Not for the authors of the article, they have moral righteousness on their side!
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:01AM (#36241153)
Perhaps in the US but London has increasingly fantastic dedicated cycle infrastructure. Removing the need for bike to ever directly interact with cars on many journeys.

Also urban fatalities of people on bikes is driven almost entirely by people driving cars. In what world do we look at the problem of cars killing people on bikes and go “well obviously the bikes are the problem”. All the stats in this area clearly indicate that drivers are far more often at fault in these collisions than those on bikes. Same again goes for pedestrians, cars kill pedestrians regardless of how careful pedestrians are.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:42AM (#36241746)
In the UK, there were 1300% more cycling fatalities than car fatalities in 2021 per the UK government[0], and this isn't controlling for differences in the kinds of miles traveled--most car fatalities happen on highways outside of the city, but these aren't the kind of miles that cyclists are doing; cycling primarily happens on slower city streets; if we account for these differences, the safety gap (with respect to occupants) grows even more considerably in favor of car transit.

[0]: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/reported-road-casua...

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:13AM (#36243222)
And yet despite that, if you live in any major city and cycle to work, your life expectancy is higher that if you drive, even if including the higher risk of a fatal collision on the road.

Transit shouldn’t be an arms race, we should be working towards making transit safe regardless of the mode of transport, not putting everyone in armoured boxes.

> No one is making this argument. We’re debating what mode of transit is safest for one’s children, not in what way we should remake society.

No, we’re discussing the validity of car free living and its value. Bring the argument that riding a bike is dangerous for children means we should put every child in car is a silly and intellectually dishonest argument. Just like the argument that the solution to “bad guys with guns” is more “good guys with guns”, when the answer is clearly fewer guns. The same applies to cars, the answer to children being killed by drivers isn’t “more cars for kids” it’s fewer cars and safer roads.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#36243924)
> And yet despite that, if you live in any major city and cycle to work, your life expectancy is higher that if you drive, even if including the higher risk of a fatal collision on the road.

Probably not causal as you're suggesting. It's probably something like "if you have the money to live near your workplace, you can probably afford great healthcare, a gym membership, great healthy food options, and other things that cause one to live longer".

> Transit shouldn’t be an arms race, we should be working towards making transit safe regardless of the mode of transport, not putting everyone in armoured boxes.

This is a straw man. I'm not advocating an arms race or "putting everyone in armoured boxes", I'm saying that a rational decision for individuals who prize their children's safety is to not allow them to cycle as a primary form of transit.

> No, we’re discussing the validity of car free living and its value. Bring the argument that riding a bike is dangerous for children means we should put every child in car is a silly and intellectually dishonest argument. Just like the argument that the solution to “bad guys with guns” is more “good guys with guns”, when the answer is clearly fewer guns. The same applies to cars, the answer to children being killed by drivers isn’t “more cars for kids” it’s fewer cars and safer roads.

You're mistaken, the comment you responded to was "I’m not sure I’d be comfortable with a young child on a bike." This is clearly not a "how should we retailor society?" claim, it's a "in our existing society, what is safest for my kid?" claim. If you manifest a society in which cycling is comparably safe to driving, I'll send my kid to school by bike.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @06:38PM (#36250216)
> Respectfully, I think you're mistaken, the comment you responded to was "I’m not sure I’d be comfortable with a young child on a bike." This is clearly not a "how should we retailor society?" claim, it's a "in our existing society, what is safest for my kid?" claim. If you manifest a society in which cycling is comparably safe to driving, I'll send my kid to school by bike.

If you’re just going to cherry pick comments from a thread chain, and ignore the rest of the discussion, then there isn’t much point discussing anything with you.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:50PM (#36251613)
Lol it’s “cherry-picking” to point out the comment you literally replied to directly? Wild stuff, mate.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by zo1 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:02AM (#36241160)
I feel like we're over-optimizing in some way. Like we're set down this odd path that only leads to more "products" and more "safety" and more of our value as humans being captured by companies and people "other" than ourselves or families. To this example, we're talking about saving money by not having a car and then the consequences of having a young child, and the dangers thereof, etc. Before we started down this path, we had none of those things, and children were perfectly "safe" staying at home and being home-schooled by individuals in the house. What's next, weighing the cost of a private tutor coming to your house because school is too expensive, transportation to school is too expensive, and the whole thing is too dangerous for them? /rant
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by BuyMyBitcoins on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:13AM (#36241319)
>”By why can’t we build more places like that, and making living car free easy and practical for everyone? It’s ultimately cheaper…”

This is true for new development but converting existing infrastructure is massively expensive and politically fraught. I believe people have become convinced cars are bad but haven’t truly realized the sheer amount of money and time it would take to redesign and reconstruct cities and suburbs in the US.

I’m not saying it shouldn’t be done. Just that the effort required will take generations, perhaps centuries, to actually come to fruition. In the meantime people shouldn’t be exasperated when wondering why we don’t just redevelop our cities.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by avianlyric on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:17AM (#36243322)
The Netherlands looks at lot like the U.S. 30 years ago, and now it’s the cycling Mecca of the world.

That isn’t to argue that the U.S. can pull off the same trick in the same manner, but it clearly demonstrates that is possible to achieve in a single generation. A big part to achieving that change was simply changing laws to make it possible, and replacing car infrastructure with shared car and cycle infrastructure as part of the normal infrastructure replacement process.

In the U.S. today, it’s almost impossible to build anything except suburbs of single family home due to zoning laws. So a good first step for the U.S. would simply be changing zoning laws to make it possible to even build dense urban areas with transit, rather than only urban sprawl.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by masswerk on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:36AM (#36240853)
This is what you'll get, if you consider public transport just a residual option for the "failures in life" (© M. Thatcher): not depending on personal transport becomes a privilege of those living in a walkable city in a suitable situation of life. (Consider yourself taxed, otherwise.)

(Disclosure: enjoying this kind of privileges, I ditched my car in the early 2000s, without regret.)

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by masswerk on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:54AM (#36241075)
BTW, one of the benefits of a functional, socially mixed public transport system is being confronted with a diverse population, which helps with not becoming trapped in a bubble. (Which may be exactly the "failure" according to M. Thatcher.)
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by Puts on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:25AM (#36240718)
Are you personally offended by someone sharing their experience of living without a car? Maybe people in the writers situation have never reflected about this lifestyle before because they take the car for granted and now he inspired people to try to live without a car. That doesn't mean that everybody needs to stop using their car – especially if they are dependent on it.

Whenever someone reacts strongly just because someone else share their personal experience of different life choices whether it's ditching the car or going vegetarian or anything progressive I can't help think it's their own guilt speaking.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by rootusrootus on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:40AM (#36240895)
These car conversations always go the same way. Some people just want to live their life the way they want, other people want to tell them it's wrong and they should feel bad.

> whether it's ditching the car or going vegetarian or anything progressive I can't help think it's their own guilt speaking

As a progressive, I find that sort of attitude a little grating. Can't imagine what it's like for conservatives.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:50AM (#36241009)
Indeed. The grandparent criticized TFA for seeming smug and the parent responds with “it’s your guilt speaking”. Wild stuff.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:34AM (#36241634)
If the article was written like that, sure. Bit it wasn't, so I responded.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by ourmandave on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:18AM (#36240630)
Given bus service where I am, my commute would go from 10 minutes one-way to literally 2 hours.

I'd lose on the sleep getting up 2 hours earlier, but gain on fitness walking a 1/4 mile to the bus stop.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by asutekku on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:12AM (#36240560)
It really depends on what taxi service you use, but on a long run it can be cheaper and more convenient than owning a car, if you do not need to use it every day.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:44AM (#36240947)
I have a hard time buying the convenience aspect unless you have taxis driving by your front door regularly. Having to call or use an app to schedule a ride is tedious, and occasionally I’ve had taxis and rideshare blow me off for a better fare. Owning a car is an expense, but it’s much more convenient than the alternatives IMHO.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by petecooper on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:13AM (#36240572)
>The smugness and naivety in that article is grating.

It's The Guardian – not the first time, certainly won't be the last. See also:

  https://unherd.com/2020/11/why-i-had-to-leave-the-guardian/
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:30AM (#36240776)
Thanks for that, a fascinating read.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @11:13AM (#36243217)
Not sure why you're getting downvoted, god forbid a journalist writes something honest.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway-kr on Friday June 16, 2023 @06:21AM (#36354214)
I am not sure why this is downvoted, The Grauniad is well known for bleating smugness.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by globular-toast on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:24AM (#36240706)
You rely on your car because you have a car and chose to rely on it. Of course he could afford £250. That's the price of one annual service these days.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by smileysteve on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:27AM (#36240737)
It's $168 average for US car insurance per month too.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:18AM (#36240635)
This is how most of my conversations with “ideological cyclists” (for lack of a better term) tend to go. I’m very supportive of cycling, but if you aren’t healthy or if you have kids giving up your car is enormously inconvenient. Yes, you can teach your kids to ride, but cycling is still much more dangerous than driving. Yes, you can rent a car or get an uber as needed, but it’s far more convenient to just jump in one’s own car. Yes, you can prepare for really cold or precipitous weather to a degree, but it’s way more convenient to simply not have to monitor the weather all the time and tote around your extra cycling clothes. And there’s really nothing you can do about hot weather unless your destination has a shower or you can otherwise make do with being sweaty.

When you add up all of these decently-sized inconveniences, it just doesn’t make sense to do away with your car except perhaps in certain ideal situations (healthy, no kids, urban/great public transit, close to work, not traveling out of the area to visit family often, etc). The best I can realistically do is family car + bike.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by ubermonkey on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:39AM (#36240891)
Exactly.

What's infuriating about these all or nothing articles is the exclusion of "car lite" approaches.

Over time and kind of slowly, my wife and I realized we really only needed one car. When the market moved around to make selling one of them way way too attractive, we did so (it was an older Porsche, and the market for those went UTTERLY NUTS -- I had it for nearly 20 years and sold it for about 85% what I paid for it).

That was really fine until she took a different job that was no longer public-transit friendly (ironically, it's a job working for the city). I think most couples would've sighed and bought a second car, but we really, really didn't want to -- so we bought a small motorcycle instead. While not suitable for the freeways, provides JUST ENOUGH supplemental mobility that the idea of a second car seems absurd now (especially given the price; the bike was $4800 and gets 80mpg).

(We DID think about ebikes, but they cost almost as much without providing nearly the utility.)

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:33AM (#36240814)
And good luck getting your five year old to ride 20km...

I think the sensible thing (assuming affording the car in the first place is fine), is to make good decisions about when to use a car or bike or walk or use transit. It doesn't have to be binary, much as everything except gender seems to be these days.

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by daneel_w on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:54AM (#36241071)
> "... or if you have kids giving up your car is enormously inconvenient."

> "Yes, you can teach your kids to ride, but cycling is still much more dangerous than driving."

> "Yes, you can rent a car or get an uber as needed, but it’s far more convenient to just jump in one’s own car."

> "Yes, you can prepare for really cold or precipitous weather to a degree, but it’s way more convenient to simply not have to monitor the weather all the time and tote around your extra cycling clothes."

> "And there’s really nothing you can do about hot weather unless your destination has a shower or you can otherwise make do with being sweaty."

> "The best I can realistically do is family car + bike."

I don't think I've ever seen or heard anyone before portraying the weather and transporting oneself without a car as such an ordeal and struggle. Though, if you life well outside the city I can understand the position.

When I grew up (in what was then a ~230k pop. city) only one single kid in my class had parents that cared about having a car, and all of us managed just fine getting to and from school, friends and various activities by foot, bicycle and public transport. We survived, and we turned out OK - perhaps more than OK, with a bit of the fortitude of not expecting or requiring constant conveniences or suffering the perspective that any transport without car is "enormously inconvenient".

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by throwaway894345 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @12:59PM (#36245083)
> I don't think I've ever seen or heard anyone before portraying the weather and transporting oneself without a car as such an ordeal and struggle. Though, if you life well outside the city I can understand the position.

You probably live in a pretty mild climate. In my part of the planet, temperatures range from -20F to 110F and we get a decent amount of precipitation. Moreover, the average commute exceeds 10 miles, and low population density means public transit options are at best poor but more likely nonexistent.

Interestingly, even in countries famous for their cycling infrastructure, car ownership (and average car weight) is increasing. It seems it's hard to beat the convenience of driving. E.g.:

* Netherlands: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/358798695_The_wides...

* Denmark: https://backend.orbit.dtu.dk/ws/portalfiles/portal/234032816...

Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by wschfdkbrmcdf on Thursday June 08, 2023 @08:25AM (#36240713)
You vill own naaaasink unt be haapy!
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by 28304283409234 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:23AM (#36241463)
Since selling our car we've been saving an extra 250 per month(!). Yes, we can now afford taxis on the rare moments we need one.
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by agentgumshoe on Thursday June 08, 2023 @09:33AM (#36241624)
Well it's a good thing you didn't depend on it to get to work then!
Re:I ditched my car – and improved my fitness, sleep and ban... by 28304283409234 on Thursday June 08, 2023 @02:04PM (#36246060)
That was not the point argued. But you are correct.