News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by te_chris on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @11:07PM (#3623758)
I refuse to buy music off iTunes and generally end up having to pirate artists' music if it's not available to buy in a lossless format.

I don't understand how bandcamp can offer me a choice of whatever format I want, yet apple still expect me to pay the cost of a CD for an inferior substitute. The galling bit will be when they do start selling in ALAC, they'll probably charge more for it - at which point I'll still refuse to pay for anything from iTunes..

EDIT: Downvoted why? Because I buy music off places where it's offered in good quality and not from places where it's not? This is not a hard problem to solve, hell bandcamp solved it ages ago - as did what.cd....

Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by unimpressive on Thursday February 23, 2012 @12:51AM (#3623981)
Minus the pirating bit, this; a thousand times this!

This is one of the reasons that I'm actually sad to see the CD go. When producers mastered for CD, you got the best quality that they could produce or that the CD could hold. (Whichever came first.) Now that the CD is fading into irrelevance, theres the worry that digital distribution will make the average quality of a track worse instead of what it should be, better than CD. (Though at this point I'd take parity with CD quality.) Yeah, I get it, lossless tracks take up a lot of memory. They should still be an option to purchase though. Lossless is the default state for recordings anyway.

I don't even have the equipment required to hear the difference. It just doesn't sit right with me to support a business that blatantly panders to the LCD at the expense of everyone else.

"Mastered for Itunes" Just reaffirms this for me.

Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by ugh on Thursday February 23, 2012 @02:00AM (#3624090)
I can’t tell the difference. I really can’t. Why do you think you would be able to?
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by georgieporgie on Thursday February 23, 2012 @04:04AM (#3624300)
How much have you tried? At lower bitrates (160 and under, mp3) I wouldn't notice a sound quality issue so much as I noticed that I consistently became fatigued faster than when I listened to CDs. I honestly don't know if the same holds true of higher bitrates, since by the time I started encoding those, I was listening less and the convenience outweighed potential irritation.
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by Zev on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @11:28PM (#3623795)
The galling bit will be when they do start selling in ALAC, they'll probably charge more for it - at which point I'll still refuse to pay for anything from iTunes..

On one hand, Apple did charge 30 cents to upgrade to the higher quality AAC from the DRM'd versions. On the other, they're providing even higher quality versions of any song they can now, for free.

(Not lossless, but, 256kbps AAC is far beyond the point where most people can tell the difference.)

Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by te_chris on Thursday February 23, 2012 @12:26AM (#3623926)
Exactly, they're not lossless. I don't know if they're deliberately doing it, but they've decided that audiophiles don't matter, much as they always do (see people who used to use expresscard on MBP's, film makers etc etc), and just plain ignore people who want to purchase high-quality content. Thankfully bandcamp exists and I buy off there all the time.
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by Zev on Thursday February 23, 2012 @01:03AM (#3623996)
Do you really think that most people care about their music being lossless? Let alone know what "lossless" even means? Most people want more music on their phones and iPod's, not less. Now, and not later in the afternoon after they've downloaded something 5-10x the size for a quality difference that they cannot notice.

Most people don't fit into your niche usage.

Apple is doing the best they can for the majority of the people, while still making the labels happy. Yes, it sucks if you happen to be in the minority[1]. But, you can't claim Apple isn't making a good business decision.

1. I speak as an iPhone and Mac developer who is used to Apple doing the best thing for the user, and not the developer.

Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by te_chris on Thursday February 23, 2012 @08:09PM (#3627514)
I wasn't questioning apple's business decisions, I was questioning their emerging monopoly on digital content that is making the digital market even more homogenous than the physical market was. At least in the physical market anyone could open up a music store because there were independent distributors whose sole incentive was to move product, now the incentive is to extract margins on product as Apple and Amazon negotiate directly with the labels and shut out competitors from being able to properly compete because they can't get the content. Some platforms are doing ok in this (bandcamp) but most aren't as the reality of music retail is not the long tail but the centre of the bell curve.

I'm also an Apple developer.

Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by smoody on Thursday February 23, 2012 @12:06AM (#3623871)
If you really cared (about the artist), you'd buy music in CD form and rip it, wouldn't you? Does not buying in iTunes mean that pirating is the only other option?
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by te_chris on Thursday February 23, 2012 @12:30AM (#3623939)
The music lobby has decided that (in some cases) iTunes is the only digital retailer they'll supply, so actually yes, it sometimes does.

Sums it up nicely: http://theoatmeal.com/comics/game_of_thrones

Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by georgieporgie on Thursday February 23, 2012 @04:07AM (#3624302)
Uh. Can you give an example of music that you want to download, but can't buy on physical CD?
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by danieldk on Thursday February 23, 2012 @04:54AM (#3624388)
There's plenty of older music that is not available on CD anymore (or has never been), but can be purchased via iTunes. To give an example: most of Sam Rivers' albums. Or Old and New Dreams (ECM).
Re:Mastered for iTunes: how audio engineers tweak tunes for ... by CrazedGeek on Thursday February 23, 2012 @08:21AM (#3624798)
A random recent viral example: http://amzn.com/B003MV33JY

Video game soundtracks tend to be hit hard by this too -- roughly half the soundtracks I want are download only, and about 2/3 of the ones available on CD are Japan only (and frequently out of print).