More specifically, you are entirely ignoring the context here.
> Other intelligence officials, both active and retired, with knowledge of these programs through their work in various agencies, have independently provided similar, corroborating information, both on and off the record.
> The whistleblower, David Charles Grusch, 36, a decorated former combat officer in Afghanistan, is a veteran of the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA) and the National Reconnaissance Office (NRO). He served as the reconnaissance office’s representative to the Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Task Force from 2019-2021. From late 2021 to July 2022, he was the NGA’s co-lead for UAP analysis and its representative to the task force.
Fragments, please. Or photos, or at least reasonably credible scientific reports describing these fragments. Or at least something resembling, you know -- first-hand evidence. Otherwise there's nothing to talk about here.
Can't believe I have to explain this on HN.
I mean sure -- he's a great guy, and has served his country and all. But still.
This guy has worked exactly where it is necessary in order to get hold of the claimed information, in a faculty with the necessary clearances.
Again, you are putting the cart before the horse by demanding "evidence" of some mystical quality, while entirely ignoring the information that is actually presented.
There is geopolitical advantage to making the world think you have advanced weapons tech, or that it exists and has to be found somewhere.
Here, the guy has supporting testimony from a whole array of decorated people in important positions. The context checks out. To assume he was "lying" is what is preposterous.
You frame the events as if some noname-guy came up in a vacuum claiming incredible stuff. That is not at all what is happening. You not knowing about all that and not even recognizing that this circumstance is affecting your judgement is remarkable.
I mean, I hope it’s true. Aliens would be cool. But we’ve been here before.
That he isn't no-name makes the lie more plausible of course. We're talking hypothetical and possibilities here, that you're completely rejecting the possibility of a government lie is pretty silly.
>supporting testimony from a whole array of decorated people in important positions
C'mon man lol.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_and_weapons_of_mass_destr...
If you assume, this guy was lying on behalf of the government you might want to try to rationalize that, because it doesn't make any sense whatsoever.
That idea about the US wanting to impress other nations with bogus UFO tech is ridiculously stupid. You completely underestimate other countries for instance.
I think "lying on behalf of the government" happens like...constantly. (See: war in ukraine) I don't really think this guy is lying, but ruling it out is...well, "ridiculously stupid."
It doesn't have to be rationalized. There's a littany of reasons we could invent that could justify lying about UFOs. This government has many foolish people in positions of power. Those people in, in theory, can do foolish things that don't make any sense whatsoever.
And the claim we're up against is literally aliens. You gotta bring receipts on that, and war medals aren't enough.
I'm highly interested to see this develop, and I haven't chosen sides yet. I would fucking LOVE to see what the world does if they get smacked in the face with proof of aliens. I am giddy with excitement.
But I'm not taking this guy's word for it, yet.
In a world of agencies famously riddled with incompetence, whose people have not only have been shown to be liars, time and time again -- but guess what: Their very purpose is to lie.
That's why we need something more to seek our teeth into than some whistleblower who says he's seen reports about such and such.
Why are you, then, hallucinating that he's some kind of "witness"?
The guy has done a seven hour interview with Ross Coulthart, that is due to come out today. He is reported to have such photos, documents, etc.
This story is bigger than Watergate by orders of magnitude. You playing ignorant here is ridiculous.
On top of it you pretend to be able to judge the validity of "artifacts". That is mere posturing.
You miss the slightly more important point of having been lied to your entire life by the government about fundamental topics, which is beginning to unravel here.
Right -- and so far there's an accumulation of precisely zero.
On top of it you pretend to be able to judge the validity of "artifacts".
I defer largely to (legitimate) experts, actually. But as of yet: there are no artifacts to evaluate.
You not knowing about the already existing evidence is no proof of its inexistence.
What "legitimate experts" exactly are you referring to and where?
The whistleblower here is talking, among other important things, about a secret US military program attempting to reverse engineer non-human artifacts. Your demands here are out of context and nonsensical.
And hey, you can believe whatever you want about this stuff. I really don't care. I do find most of the line of discussion here to be quite silly, though.
Until then -- all I'm saying is: C'mon, people -- hold your horses.
We're scientists here, after all.
What you are is unclear to me.
And yet, when you actually listened to what the guy was saying ...
I don't know though, whether Colin Powell risked his career in any way, it doesn't look like it.
You are weirdly not providing any reasoned arguments whatsoever, only illogical slander. Why is that?
I think it's clear we're talking past each other by this point. Again, you can fit this news story into your head however you like.
As it stands now -- we have nothing.
Your attempts to relativize that with nonsensical "Let's put the cart before the horse and our heads in the sand"-arguments are misleading.
There have been "Retired intelligence officer says he has evidence of aliens" stories floating in fringe media for decades, and all of them have turned out to be cranks. Bob Lazar has been working this beat since 1989; where's the evidence?
Maybe eventually one of these times it'll all be true, but skepticism -- extreme skepticism -- should absolutely be the default position here.
A real skeptic actually looks at the data and isn't content simply by ignoring it.
Here, you simply imply this guy was a "crank". Maybe you should take a closer look first?
There, is a Stanford Professor good enough for you?
This is also referenced in the article: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237309319_On_Events...
The original article seems to be implying that there's like some extraordinary clear evidence of a vehicle or something, which would be much more shocking.
Your depiction of the story is clearly misleading. This here is a mere step in the direction of uncovering such "material evidence" as you would like to be presented right now, as if reality ever worked that way.
lisasays: this is rubbish because there's no first-hand evidence e.g. of the vehicle fragments of the Debrief article
phyallow: here's first-hand evidence [link to the vice article]
me: this is just weird bits of rock, which isn't obviously a vehicle fragment, and so this article isn't really as much of a proper response to lisasays' comment as it seems.
(2) By my reading, the stuff he's talking about doesn't constitute (or even suggest) dispositive evidence of alien craft. Nor this guy even claiming that they are. All he's saying basically, is "Here's some fragments / MRI scans we don't understand, let's explore further".
(3) Even so, this stuff is many orders of magnitude weaker than the claims in the original article (literally "intact craft of alien origin"). So there's not even an analogy to be made here.
Although I guess for (2), his quote in the OP article does imply that he believes that these could be alien craft.
Weird. Definitely less reason to take this guy seriously. And really irresponsible and stupid of Vox to put an out of context quote like that out there, as if it says anything useful about anything.
"Grusch also said he has not seen photos of the alleged craft himself, but has spoken extensively with other intelligence officials who have." from https://www.newsnationnow.com/space/military-whistleblowe-us...
Do you suppose, he could have carted one of the vehicles out the facilitie or something?
Hearsay is a TYPE of evidence, albeit not a particularly reliable type of evidence. But you are correct, it is hearsay, and in fact, its second-hand hearsay.
But more to Loquebantur's point here (I think this was his point), this IS fundamentally different than similar claims that came before. You have one guy from the government making these sorts of claims (that's not the different part, this next part is), and you have 2 other decorated government officials and colleagues willing to, not only speaking highly of Grusch's integrity, but CORROBORATING HIS EXACT CLAIMS, and even going on to provide a further anecdotes. That's not what normally happens. Also, it is fundamentally different for this reason as well: All of this information and whatever Grusch learned was provided to congress, behind closed door to those with the clearance to hear it. As far as I am aware of, this level of type of information has never been provided to congress before.
This not insignificant; Congress has the the power to subpoena information, compel testimony, and ultimately verify or debunk these claims and information. And ultimately, if they deem it pertinent to do so, they have the autonomy to inform the American public.
Now, not to totally invalidate your other point: I do think it is important to keep in mind here that Grusch himself has not seen any direct or hard evidence of 'materials of exotic origin'. He is merely saying that several high-level individuals have confided in him what is presumably first hand experiences, which, as you know, is second-hand hearsay.
So this leaves open the possibility that the individuals who were confiding in Grusch, were fooling themselves, were in some way deceived, or perhaps even wanting to fool Grusch himself.
Also of course the energy required to get to Earth from somewhere else, for an organism that used any kind of "vehicle" we could recognize as such, would be enormous.
But, good to stay open-minded.
I agree that probably there needs to be more evidence than "trust me, I've done this for a long time" in order for us to assert there is extra-terrestrial intelligence. But, I wouldn't believe it's false just based on "it couldn't have been hidden for this long".
Not only is there an enormous backstory attached that people willfully choose to remain ignorant to, all kinds of people holding active positions in the highest relevant places are corroborating this.
Even more importantly perhaps, part of the story is a decades-long disinformation program conducted against the US population and government itself, by rouge elements in the intelligence community.
For one thing your assumption here just isn't true. You might have been called that in major media outlets -- but within the tech community it had been widely acknowledged (since the late 90s or so) that such surveillance was most likely happening. And precursors of such technology were referenced in congressional hearings back in the 70s. This was all discussed openly and there was nothing conspiratorial about the topic at all.
For another -- just because certain things in the past that have been derided as conpiracy-fodder and then turned out to be true (MKULTRA, say) doesn't mean that some other thing X (that you happen to find nifty to believe in at the moment) just might be true, or will also be validated as such some day.
In short -- the presence "conspiracy-nut" stigma about something has no bearing on its scientific validity whatsoever. Either for or against.
But, I wouldn't believe it's false just based on "it couldn't have been hidden for this long".
No - one wisely judges them to be most likely false based on (1) lack of physical evidence, (2) Occam's Razor. Not because of what you're saying (which doesn't have any bearing on the topic at all).
You realize how easily this point can be applied to UFO discourse, right?
There is a huge UAP community of believers. I don't see why a community belief makes it more legitimate. It's speculation until you have hard evidence, for the NSA thing that evidence was a whistleblower, what's the difference here??
That, along with black special access programs (like described in the article), covered with classified programs, is how you keep it, not secret, but "partially occluded."
The question is not: how? But: why? The answer is because they were afraid and in denial because it challenged their authority, and they wanted us to be in the same fear and denial, because then they can maintain "control".
Maybe now it's shifted. And that's good. Not because everybody gets to know there's aliens, but because the governing corporate superstructure is choosing to no longer continue to act like scared little idiots. And I think that will be better for all of us.
I'm not saying this is true or false, but if it's true, we'd expect no actual evidence.
I'm not sure what to say to that.
This is the governing superstructure’s chance to step up. I hope it takes it
Extraordinary claims -- extraordinary evidence.
Show us some of these fragments, please. You know, the ones with the special "vehicle morphologies", the "unique atomic arrangements and radiological signatures" and stuff.
Otherwise, there's nothing to talk about here. And nothing fundamentally different from these claims than in all those glaring headlines we've been glancing past, at the top of few certain supermarket tabloids that don't need to be named -- for half a century now.