News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pixar lays off animator who saved Toy Story 2 with car fu... by robertlagrant on Monday June 05, 2023 @11:36AM (#36197819)
> Having done great work in the past is not enough to incentivize others to keep you around.

Happening to have a backup copy in your house 25 years ago doesn't justify your current role of being good at losing the company millions of dollars. Disney and Pixar have had a series of movies that in the main have had bad production and writing decisions attached to them, so even though the technical delivery (e.g. animation; music) and performances are generally very good, they are just boring. A lot of the spark seems to have gone.

If you watch the latest Disney or Pixar movies and compare it with something like the Arcane TV series, which is unbelievably beautifully animated and extremely well written, it's night and day. The talent that led Pixar has fizzled or been replaced over the years, and they can't pay people a fortune to lose them money forever.

Re:Pixar lays off animator who saved Toy Story 2 with car fu... by jakelazaroff on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:00PM (#36198273)
I'm not convinced you're putting the blame in the right place. Looking at the last decade or so, most of the original films — Inside Out, Coco, Luca, Turning Red, etc — have ranged from "great" to "incredible". It's the sequels and spinoffs like Cars 3, Toy Story 4 and Lightyear that have fallen flat. I don't know where in the Disney org chart people start worrying about revenue, but from where I sit Pixar still has plenty of spark.
Re:Pixar lays off animator who saved Toy Story 2 with car fu... by robertlagrant on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:36PM (#36198895)
Er - I'm not sure about that. Toy Story 4 took in over a billion[0] worldwide. Coco and Inside Out did around $800m[1] each, but Luca did very poorly, taking under $50m.[2].

Turning Red appears to be the worst, on a $250m budget (and probably similar for marketing, it took $20m[3].

[0] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt1979376

[1] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt2380307

[2] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt12801262

[3] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt8097030

Re:Pixar lays off animator who saved Toy Story 2 with car fu... by jakelazaroff on Monday June 05, 2023 @12:48PM (#36199099)
I mean, it’s entirely unsurprising to me that established IPs pull more at the box office than new ones — that’s the whole reason they keep churning out them out! Like, look at the top box office grosses [1]: the list is absolutely dominated by giant franchises, sequels and remakes.

Anyway, I’m much more interested in talking about what I thought you were originally: the qualitative “creative spark” that makes (or made) Pixar movies so special.

[1] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/chart/top_lifetime_gross/?area...

Re:Pixar lays off animator who saved Toy Story 2 with car fu... by gamblor956 on Monday June 05, 2023 @02:33PM (#36200882)
Turning Red was not released theatrically in the U.S., it was a Disney+ release that did not require a separate purchase (unlike the Mulan remake) so the fact it still made $20m is quite impressive. Based on the numbers for Poland, UAE, etc. in the BoxOfficeMojo link, Turning Red would likely have made over $600m globally if it had been released theatrically in major markets.

As other commenters have noted, Turning Red was the second most watched films on streaming in 2022, across all platforms (Luca was #9.)

Re:Pixar lays off animator who saved Toy Story 2 with car fu... by tzs on Monday June 05, 2023 @06:27PM (#36204964)
> Coco and Inside Out did around $800m each, but Luca did very poorly, taking under $50m.

Coco had a domestic theatrical release and was in theaters in over 50 other countries.

Luca did not get a domestic theatrical release (except for one week in one theater). Internationally it was in theaters in 20 countries. Similar for Turning Red except it was only in theaters in 17 countries.

Luca and to a lesser extent Turning Red did reasonably well in those countries where they were actually in theaters considering that it was during a pandemic when attendance was down. If they had been released in theaters in a non-pandemic year and in all the countries Coco was in they would have probably been at least $500m movies.

Luca was the most streamed movie of 2021 (10.6x10^9 minutes of streaming) (and it was #9 in 2022 with another 5x10^9 minutes) , and Turning Red was the second most streamed movie of 2022 (11.4x10^9 minutes) (#1 was Encanto at 27.4x10^9 minutes).

BTW, Encanto did get a domestic theater release and an international theater release in almost as many countries as Coco and yet only pulled in $256m worldwide. I think that's a pretty good illustration of how much the pandemic affected box office.