News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by Zetobal on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:18PM (#36188588)
Headline is misleading and the tweets are delusional. The whole ycombinator topic he rants about has nothing to do with the lawsuit he filled.

>> So as a member of the group ‘all of humanity,’ the reported beneficiaries of OpenAI, I have filed a claim for Breach of Fiduciary Duties. Breach of Fiduciary Duties is the umbrella my complaints generally fall under. The board members of OpenAI have a legal duty to serve the mission of the non-profit in good faith, to act prudently, and to obey the law, all of which they are not doing. OpenAI has constantly confirmed via public messaging their mission is to “benefit all of humanity;” the only logical conclusion to these statements is that all of humanity, you, me, and people on every continent, are beneficiaries of OpenAI’s mission. I firmly believe, and state in good faith, that every human being on the planet has standing to sue OpenAI for these egregious actions. Further, I look forward to hearing the legal team of OpenAI explain how this is not the case. If anyone has any illusions about the altruistic intentions of OpenAI, their explanation should put these illusions to bed.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by belter on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:27PM (#36188681)
Courtesy of ChatGPT. I think we can appreciate the irony here.

Q: I have a legal question. What happens if members of a non-profit organization, work to provide privileged access to the non-profit organization assets, to one of their for profit companies?

A: Engaging in such activities could potentially result in serious legal and ethical consequences. This kind of activity may violate laws related to conflicts of interest, self-dealing, and misuse of non-profit assets.

Here are some potential legal implications:

Violation of Fiduciary Duties: Non-profit directors and officers have fiduciary duties of care, loyalty, and obedience to the organization. Using the non-profit's assets for personal gain or for the benefit of a for-profit company could be seen as a breach of these duties.

Self-Dealing: This is a term used in the IRS tax code to describe transactions that occur between a non-profit and its insiders or directors. It is generally prohibited for insiders to use their position to benefit personally from transactions with the organization.

Loss of Tax-Exempt Status: If the non-profit is found to be engaging in such activities, it could lose its tax-exempt status. The IRS requires that a non-profit's assets be used exclusively for its exempt purposes.

Reputational Damage: Even if a legal case is not pursued, this kind of action can seriously damage the reputation of the non-profit organization, which can in turn impact its fundraising capabilities and relationship with the public and other stakeholders.

Personal Liability: Depending on the state's laws and the specific circumstances, the directors or officers involved could potentially be held personally liable for the misappropriation of assets.

In such cases, it is always advised to seek legal counsel for the proper understanding and resolution. It's important to note that while this general advice should be useful, it's always advisable to speak with an attorney or legal expert who can advise based on the specifics of the situation and local jurisdictional laws.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by Zetobal on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:37PM (#36188791)
It seems like you asked chatgpt about something you misinterpreted in the first place.Thats a really good way to gaslight yourself. Look at the company structure of OpenAI...

I am no fan of Sam either but come on.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by belter on Sunday June 04, 2023 @03:58PM (#36188990)
This is from the OpenAI pages "OpenAI LP’s primary fiduciary obligation is to advance the aims of the OpenAI Charter, and the company is controlled by OpenAI Nonprofit’s board. All investors and employees sign agreements that OpenAI LP’s obligation to the Charter always comes first, even at the expense of some or all of their financial stake."

Whether this is what's really going on or not, it's up to the courts to sort it out, or maybe it'll get sorted out without going to court. Since there's some past beef with other big-name billionaires, curious reporters should check out if there's someone else footing the bill for what could be a really pricey lawsuit.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by tensor on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:02PM (#36189030)
It takes a 30s google search to find the Wikipedia page which explains their transition to a "capped-profit" company. Irony of asking ChatGPT instead of a simple search indeed.
Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by OnlineGladiator on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:32PM (#36189314)
The real irony is not noticing that this is the standard way people use ChatGPT and instead saying "you're using it wrong" - which is a convenient holier-than-thou argument that ignores the negative repercussions of this technology that we are literally observing and commenting on. If this is what ChatGPT mostly leads to - a wild amplification of fake news - then it's also ironic that OpenAI is claiming to make the world a better place.

GP did a perfect job of using ChatGPT the way most of the world uses it - as a shortcut for doing any real research or work. This inevitably leads to misinformation being spread and it's palpable how often I see people cite ChatGPT's hallucinations as confirmation of their own bias. I really don't give a fuck about how people should use it compared to how they are using it. You cannot manifest a different reality with aphorisms.

I'm not claiming this is a worthless technology with no positive benefits. I'm saying right now I can already observe enormous negative effects from this technology, and the upside seems relatively underwhelming.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by catchnear4321 on Monday June 05, 2023 @07:55AM (#36195048)
> I'm saying right now I can already observe enormous negative effects from this technology, and the upside seems relatively underwhelming.

> GP did a perfect job of using ChatGPT the way most of the world uses it

the enormous negative effects are just perfectly normal human behavior, amplified. better to deal with the root cause than continue to act like technology is the danger.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by kordlessagain on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:23PM (#36189237)
There is a consistent inconsistency which is that people think because a model was trained “on the Internet” it “knows everything” on it.

Hardly.

Re:OpenAI is getting sued for being biased with Y Combinator by belter on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:08PM (#36189102)
The structure is well known, and is neither what is being argued in the lawsuit, or asked from ChatGPT. I am not commenting on the merits of it, that is for the courts.

So what is your take? Are they on it for Profit or to save Humanity? Should we nominate already Sam Altman and Reid Hoffman for the Nobel Peace this year?