News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by nomilk on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:14AM (#36183930)
The title evoked my curiosity but I'm procrastinating and don't have time for the lengthy article, so pasted the title into ChatGPT (4) without modification. It returned:

> Crushed stones, also known as ballast, serve several purposes in the construction and maintenance of railway tracks:

> Stability: The stones provide a stable base for the railway tracks, helping to hold the wooden cross ties in place, which in turn hold the rails upright and maintain the proper gauge, or distance between the rails.

> Drainage: The stones improve drainage around the tracks, preventing water accumulation that could lead to track deformation or weakening of the substrate.

> Distribute Load: The stones help distribute the load of the trains evenly across the foundation, reducing the overall stress on the underlying ground.

> Prevent Vegetation Growth: The ballast makes it difficult for vegetation to grow, which could interfere with the track structure.

> Dampen Vibration: The stones help to absorb some of the vibrations and noise produced by passing trains.

The 5 subheadings are bolded in the GPT response enabling even faster scanning. Seems quite accurate too!

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ggambetta on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:21AM (#36183958)
Honest question, genuinely curious, I'm not picking on you; what's the point of pasting a ChatGPT response to a question? I've seen colleagues do this on internal mailing lists, even some of my friends do this on our group chats.

I really don't get it. If I wanted the opinion of a language model, I'd ask a language model (and I do semi-frequently for certain questions). Getting ChatGPT output from an human rubs me the wrong way, like getting a LMGTFY link.

But I assume both in your case and my friend's that the intent isn't to be passive aggressive. Help me understand?

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by nomilk on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:26AM (#36183988)
Reason for posting: I was surprised at how economical (in terms of words and, most importantly, reader time) GPT was compared to a human in answering the same question.

Thanks for pointing out that it's distracting and unnecessary (I hadn't considered that before posting and I agree with you, and happy for this to be removed/downvoted).

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by drewwwwww on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:07AM (#36184403)
the output of LLMs is not novel to this audience
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by ishvanl on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:21AM (#36184723)
Well, the original post isn't about how particularly efficient ChatGPT is at stripping all of the character and large amounts of information from a perfectly good source. The original post is about railway ballast, and as such, this comment is completely and utterly irrelevant.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by buildbot on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:23AM (#36183971)
I've seen this ~10 times today - They are all phrased the same way too. This person seems like an actual person and not a bot, so IDK. It's really, really annoying. If we wanted to, we could ask chatgpt ourselves.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by martyvis on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:29AM (#36184005)
Clearly they all want to welcome their AI overlords.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by PrimeMcFly on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:26AM (#36183993)
I assume they (and your co-worker) are just sharing something they thought was interesting and wanted to save people time from asking themselves. Like finding a source and pasting it even though everyone could google and find it themselves.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by codeflo on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:23AM (#36183970)
I know you might have done this for the first time, but there’s a response like this in every HN thread now. Please stop doing it.

It’s fine to discuss GPT in GPT threads (there’s no shortage of those). But this adds nothing to the discussion of the actual topic: The fact that it may or may not be hallucinated means that others would have to fact check the post, which means that in terms of net time, this adds negative value.

I’m not trying to be harsh, it’s not personally about you. I’m just hoping that a trend that significantly degrades the information value of HN doesn’t continue.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by dragonne on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:21AM (#36183959)
If you consider this article lengthy you should read a few books to recalibrate your attention span.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by DonHopkins on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:13AM (#36184427)
Announcing to everyone that you didn't bother reading the article because you don't have time, but then wasting your own time playing around with ChatGTP, then wasting everyone else's time by posting something everyone who actually did bother reading the article already knows, is hypocritical and disrespectful of everyone's time, and adds nothing to the conversation.

If you didn't bother reading the article, then simply don't post anything, especially not an announcement you didn't read the article.

Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by d13 on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:32AM (#36184028)
I’m pretty sure the article is GPT generated too.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by Kaibeezy on Sunday June 04, 2023 @05:23AM (#36184231)
I asked ChatGPT to write an HN comment thread on this topic and posted the whole thing here. - Nick
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by paulmooreparks on Sunday June 04, 2023 @07:55AM (#36184905)
Even GPT wouldn't use "extremely" that many times.
Re:Why do railway tracks have crushed stones alongside them? by eloisius on Sunday June 04, 2023 @04:22AM (#36183963)
Please don’t start posting LLM summaries. If anyone wants this summary they can query chatGPT themselves. It’s just noise.