Re:The Newest College Admissions Ploy: Paying to Make Your T...
by civilized on Saturday June 03, 2023 @12:42PM
(#36178147)
This is a calculation on the distribution of admitted students. It isn't relevant to my point that elite colleges stand to benefit from admitting more legacies regardless of test performance.
If anything, if Harvard only admits high-performing legacies today, it only bolsters the case for how much more legacies they could admit with a more opaque, "holistic" process.
Which, mind you, is something similar to other things they've done historically.
Re:The Newest College Admissions Ploy: Paying to Make Your T...
by onetimeusename on Saturday June 03, 2023 @01:01PM
(#36178325)
ya that's valid. I don't think there is a clean answer about who should be admitted but my attempt was just to show that the dumb legacy trope doesn't seem to be completely factual. But yes, children of Harvard alumni probably have an advantage. But then again the legacies may be talented students.
I found that only 2% of the incoming class would be theoretical white people who were admitted with legacy status and who fell to the left of 1 std dev in SAT score. If these people exist, I don't know what other circumstances might exist for them. Their SAT score is still high by US standards and they may be athletes or overlap with some other category for all I know or something else.
I think the below average legacy admit trope is actually deployed as a racial stereotype of white students that the SFFA, who are Asian, are using to gain access to Harvard. I don't think the hypothetical upper bound of 2% which is ~40 students is meaningful.
Now there is one issue with this which is that we don't have legacy student SAT scores broken down by race. But other sources suggest legacy students are disproportionately white. This is not true of the student body generally.