News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by MrGagi on Saturday June 03, 2023 @08:24AM (#36176061)
“It would be a real mistake to think that when you’re teaching a child, all you are doing is adjusting the weights in a network.”
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by Waterluvian on Saturday June 03, 2023 @08:41AM (#36176197)
This is what I think is going to hold us back. The worry, perhaps subconsciously, of discovering that consciousness is much less complex and exceptional than we might want it to be.

I have this inkling because I see a pattern: people, even incredibly smart people, explaining it away with a “but that would diminish the exceptionality of our own minds!” type of argument.

I’m struggling for the right words. Specialness, maybe? That people have this need to think that it’s special and not so easily replicated. And if it’s rather simple then it surely must not be the same because that wouldn’t be special.

Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by 0xGod on Saturday June 03, 2023 @09:33AM (#36176550)
It's not replicating it that is impressive. That part is easy. Of course consciousness wouldn't be that hard. Of course it would be mostly an emergent property of various building blocks. Of course homo sapiens would eventually be able to do the same thing.

The impressive part is replicating it and then teaching it real Love. Love is a choice. Producing life that chooses to make that choice and defend that choice is impressive.

Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by Waterluvian on Saturday June 03, 2023 @09:55AM (#36176694)
I think this is the same problem. How would you measure when a human is taught love? How would you differentiate that from measuring when one of these programs is taught love?

It feels like it always boils down to: 1) you can’t. Or 2) “trust me, it’s different.”

Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by 0xGod on Saturday June 03, 2023 @12:54PM (#36178243)
It's simple - observe what the candidate does when they have to show true love in order to move on to the next level. If they fail, they don't move on to the next level.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by Waterluvian on Saturday June 03, 2023 @04:16PM (#36180135)
That works until the AI is crashing both trolleys at the very end to get to Meryl Streep.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by MrGagi on Saturday June 03, 2023 @08:46AM (#36176232)
Yeah I agree, we still don't much about our minds, and it might turn out that we are not that special.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by Aerbil313 on Saturday June 03, 2023 @08:55AM (#36176285)
Or rather that our specialness can not be based on intellligence.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by kelseyfrog on Saturday June 03, 2023 @10:14AM (#36176850)
Turing saw the same pattern of thought. That's why he pre-emptively refutes it in the Turing test paper. He describes the argument like so

> The consequences of machines thinking would be too dreadful. Let us hope and believe that they cannot do so.[1]

1. https://redirect.cs.umbc.edu/courses/471/papers/turing.pdf

Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by netruk44 on Saturday June 03, 2023 @10:32AM (#36177018)
The idea you’re talking about is called “human exceptionalism”. It’s the idea that humans are in some way unique when it comes to being, thinking, and feeling.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by Waterluvian on Saturday June 03, 2023 @10:39AM (#36177055)
Thank you. That sounds like what I’m trying to describe.
Re:Ted Chiang: ‘The machines we have now are not conscious’ by raincole on Saturday June 03, 2023 @09:35AM (#36176567)
Or maybe it is? How does he know?