Re:Facebook and many other sites also bypass Internet Explor...
by freehunter on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @08:33AM
(#3616364)
If it's broken to begin with, it's not really "breaking the users security settings". Specifically if it can be broken just by saying "break it", then it's broken from the start.
Re:Facebook and many other sites also bypass Internet Explor...
by tripzilch on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @10:49AM
(#3616858)
In that sense NO ENTRY signs are also broken. And so is the robots.txt protocol.
Re:Facebook and many other sites also bypass Internet Explor...
by stanleydrew on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @11:24AM
(#3616997)
But "No Entry" signs and robots.txt are broken for the same reason. We all know that, so how is it a counterargument?
Re:Facebook and many other sites also bypass Internet Explor...
by freehunter on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @03:18PM
(#3617905)
No one trusts their security to a sign or a robots.txt. Get a security guard and an encrypted directory, and get a better way to manage your cookies.
Re:Facebook and many other sites also bypass Internet Explor...
by zerostar07 on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @09:08AM
(#3616451)
Even from your description, P3P does not work; IE is equally dishonest imho for claiming that P3P provides any kind of privacy.
Re:Facebook and many other sites also bypass Internet Explor...
by tripzilch on Tuesday February 21, 2012 @10:52AM
(#3616878)
It's a crappy protocol, I agree. I don't see how that's relevant though.
The fact that the invalid P3P header contains the string "We don't support P3P and here's why" is a red herring:
The only reason why they would place a statement regarding their non-support in the very header that they claim not to support, is to circumvent IE-users' privacy policy. It's very disingenuous.
If you don't support it, leave out the header, if you want to make a statement that says "We don't support the P3P header", don't put it in a place that really says
If FB or Google's headers had said that, at least it wouldn't have been as disingenious. Saying you don't support P3P--oops! and by saying that we broke it! whoops!It's a bit like placing a sticker "WE DONT SUPPORT READING THE LEFT HALF OF A SIGNPOST" over the left half of a "NO ENTRY" sign. Childish.
It would be interesting if we could see that list of other 500 companies. Because "there's 498 others that do it too" has a very different implication depending on what sort of company Google and Facebook find themselves in by acting in such a childish manner.