News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ancient lead pollution in a Roman harbor (2017) by krisoft on Thursday June 01, 2023 @06:53AM (#36149519)
> Show me a causal chain

The article itself says that the theory that Rome fell due to lead poisoning is disputed. In fact they say these then recent findings are contradicting the theory. The exact quote you didn't seem to notice:

"The city's infatuation with lead pipes led to the popular (and disputed) theory that Rome fell due to lead poisoning. Now, a new study reveals that the city's lead plumbing infrastructure was at its biggest and most complicated during the centuries leading up to the empire's peak."

> or this is yet another a puff piece from Ars.

There is something particularly odious about complaining about the lack of intellectual rigour while showing none in the same comment.

Re:Ancient lead pollution in a Roman harbor (2017) by thom on Thursday June 01, 2023 @07:42AM (#36149846)
If anything, the Romans (e.g. Vitruvius) actually _knew_ lead could be bad but even then decided it was best overall.
Re:Ancient lead pollution in a Roman harbor (2017) by bboygravity on Thursday June 01, 2023 @08:11AM (#36150052)
The city of Chicago almost 2000 years later did the exact same.
Re:Ancient lead pollution in a Roman harbor (2017) by eigenhombre on Thursday June 01, 2023 @09:03AM (#36150498)
Indeed. I live in Chicago. Several years back, mid-winter, we suddenly had a geyser in the middle of our courtyard: burst pipe. Called in experts, and several hours and one coffin-sized hole in our yard later, we had running water again. I asked them for the 10" / 25 cm spliced-out bit of pipe, and still have it -- it is amazingly heavy, and definitely lead.
Re:Ancient lead pollution in a Roman harbor (2017) by twelve40 on Thursday June 01, 2023 @09:38AM (#36150857)
but it's surely not rocket science to determine the effects of it, right? it's either so bad that a civilization can die from it, or decidedly not? especially if it's been used in recent times in Chicago, which didnt go extinct like Rome. So I'm not sure why this theory always gets reluctantly dragged along, it's either true or false.
Re:Ancient lead pollution in a Roman harbor (2017) by eigenhombre on Thursday June 01, 2023 @05:46PM (#36157809)
The jury is still out on Chicago going extinct :-) though I see your point, and I wonder how serious the problem actually is. TIL: the danger depends on your water chemistry[1], which I expect is monitored in cities like Chicago.

[1] https://www.treehugger.com/lead-in-water-pipes-4018249