So there's an incentive to do a good job here.
That said, Arrington follows his existing friends or things he's interested in. If you @ reply him he will read it but more than likely he won't respond to it. That's two problems then, 1) trying to prove you can be his friend and 2) getting him to react. If you're trying to be his friend a Twitter-Digg app is a pretty lame way of doing so. If you're trying to get him to react the simplest way is to send him compelling content or proposition.
BTW, another reason why you might upvote a message is because you would like to see Arrington's reply (assuming he will reply to it in public).
And why is seeing someone reply to something even considered an incentive?
I could be wrong. Get a copy of pligg and drop in tweets and users and see what happens.
Here's the rebuttal: 1) you need a varied enough audience that actually cared enough about his life to sift through messages directed to him and 2) if you could amass such an audience it becomes politically, or money-wise, prudent to game it for your own benefit and 3) why would he trust audiences to judge or to even read his messages?