So you are saying that if someone wrote to you from a corporate address at General Electric ge.com you wouldn't reply to an inquiry if they didn't make an offer?
And taking that one step further that person who is a serious buyer could be masking their identity behind a gmail account.
I think it's a mistake not to reply to an email. Even if just to say "not for sale make offer" or whatever you want to say.
Many times brokers (who have valid buyers with money) are inquiring. If they don't get a response they will move on.
Just my perspective I'm a big believer in always responding.
I thought this was standard practice ever since the slashdot.com debacle.
If Slashdot had owned the .com, it wouldn't have happened.
An Australian example is crikey.com.au, who for years were troubled by people referring to them as crikey.com -- in print media, on TV, even in Hansard.
Another tip: Don't play dirty. I caught someone trying to initiate a transfer on one of my domains without my knowledge. Naturally, it failed. Out of spite, I snapped up the .net and .org counterparts, which were still available. If it weren't for that dick move, I probably would have pointed out that they were there for the taking.