Re:South Australia passes law to ban “disruptive” protests
by jruohonen on Wednesday May 31, 2023 @03:36AM
(#36135571)
> is currently the best empirical source?
Yes: a lot of academic research on the topic.
> I've been about for a few decades and I'm a fan of large helicopter views of
> global parameters, resource | energy use | trade movements | political trends |
> comparative intra country wealth distribution | etc.
You can do that with V-Dem too.
> I can see it's a decent enough project, albeit influenced by both the University
> of Notre Dame and the Kellogg Institute, but I see no compelling reason to rank
> it as "the best" of it's kind and a few flags that suggest potential bias in
> viewpoint.
These are the same people; V-Dem was built upon the foundation done at the Kelogg Institute. Since then, V-Dem covers over ten universities and over two thousand academics.
> Err... I did look through the V-Dem 2023 Democracy report (56 pages), read
> several parts at length and looked at the four (4) mentions of Australia and
> while I agree that many parts of the world are backsliding to what is described
> as 1985 global democracy levels ... there is no mention there that Australia is
> one of those parts sliding back and indeed is rated there as on the world's more
> democratic nations (#11 of 190+ countries)
I just briefly looked at the chart about liberal democracy rights; a slight downward trend from the late 2000s. You'd need to do a thorough analysis for a definite conclusion, of course.
Yes: a lot of academic research on the topic.
> I've been about for a few decades and I'm a fan of large helicopter views of > global parameters, resource | energy use | trade movements | political trends | > comparative intra country wealth distribution | etc.
You can do that with V-Dem too.
> I can see it's a decent enough project, albeit influenced by both the University > of Notre Dame and the Kellogg Institute, but I see no compelling reason to rank > it as "the best" of it's kind and a few flags that suggest potential bias in > viewpoint.
These are the same people; V-Dem was built upon the foundation done at the Kelogg Institute. Since then, V-Dem covers over ten universities and over two thousand academics.
> Err... I did look through the V-Dem 2023 Democracy report (56 pages), read > several parts at length and looked at the four (4) mentions of Australia and > while I agree that many parts of the world are backsliding to what is described > as 1985 global democracy levels ... there is no mention there that Australia is > one of those parts sliding back and indeed is rated there as on the world's more > democratic nations (#11 of 190+ countries)
I just briefly looked at the chart about liberal democracy rights; a slight downward trend from the late 2000s. You'd need to do a thorough analysis for a definite conclusion, of course.