The penny dropped for me when taking the family plastics waste to our recycling drop off. There was a notice saying you couldn't put thermoformed pet items (Raspberry clamshells) because if that stuff was found in the 40' container the entire load has to be dumped in landfill. Thermoformed PET has the same number as molded PET (water bottles). I think "whaaaat are those symbols with numbers for then???" pulled out my phone, did some searching and discovered that the entire scheme is BS.
The problem with plastic is that it leaks into the environment. The only problem with a landfill solution for plastic is that not all of the plastic makes it into the landfill.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_hierarchy
You can extract metals from the ashes as you mention.
For regularly used things like drink containers it's not quite as good as recycling them though.
And as more renewables enter the grid, theres less fossil fuel to displace but if the RDF (resource derived fuel) can be stored then it acts as a kind of storage.
https://theconversation.com/ranked-the-environmental-impact-...
This discussion is a waste of time. There are two options. One is easier than the other. Like everyone else, I want to take the easier one. Period.
I can imagine ending up with a house full of glass bottles. Where does it reasonably stop for the individual?
The conversation also highlights that our intuitions about what the most environmentally friendly thing is can’t be trusted.
Individuals can’t solve this, that’s for sure.
Glass container (not reused): Ovaltine
Paper container (not reused): Chips Ahoy cookies
Cardboard container (not reused): washing detergent powder
Metal container (not reused): Hershey's chocolate powder
No institution wants to tell you it's all a lie. My municipality pick up this trash under the name of 'recycling' meanwhile some naive people are busy washing out single use containers.
Decades ago when plastic was more expensive society did it right. For example Milk and beer was sold in glass bottles you'd return. Jack up the price of these nasty materials and suddenly the easiest thing to do is actually 'recycle'.