News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our unrealistic views of death, through a doctor’s eyes by ekianjo on Monday February 20, 2012 @03:40AM (#3611768)
Good comment. I do not agree with everything you said, so let me elaborate a little.

1 - Eating too much is not the issue. Eating too much of the wrong things is the issue.

No, I assure that even if you eat too much healthy food, you will grow fat and obese the same. Unhealthy food may make it worse for a number of reasons, but excess is anyway going to be a problem, no matter what you eat.

2 - Unhealthy foods are cheaper than fresh fruits, veggies, and meat by an almost comically large margin. This is due to a number of causes, most saliently massive government subsidization of unhealthy food industries.

First, I would not classify "meat" as healthy food. That probably depends on your education and your view of meat, but you get a lot of fat percentage for the amount of calories. 50 years ago people were eating meat probably like 10 times less that we are and were (probably, I dont have numbers with me now) less sick. For your second point, "unhealthy" food is, I think, rather the result of people not considering food as important. Therefore food becomes a commodity. People prefer spending their money on vacation, video games, buying the latest smartphone and so on. Even those who HAVE the money. It's clearly a cultural problem: food has lost "value" per se. I do not know where you live so I cannot comment on that, but in most developped countries governments are also massively subsidizing small-sized farms (true in Europe and some parts of Asia at least).

3a. I agree with the time element, but I disagree in the responsibility. Of course, if one feels like you have to watch 4 hours of dumb TV shows every night to be satisfied with their lives, then there will no time for cooking. But anyone who can spare 30-45 mins a day in the evening can cook something healthy. Of course, it will not be something complex, but it is feasible. Please do not tell you need longer than that, of I will have to film myself cooking to prove my point.

3b. Now if you cannot even afford a car I admit this is a problem, especially in North America. Then it makes access to quality food more difficult. I can't argue on that one.

3c. Allright, of course there are poors who live in the worst conditions ever, and putting good food on the table is far from their priorities. But come on, when we talk about the obesity epidemic, we are talking about something like 33% of the whole US population having this obesity problem. You cannot seriously tell me that 33% of the US is composed of poor people living in crime-ridden suburbs. (http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/trends.HTML)

A number of these 33% HAVE the money, HAVE the time, HAVE the means to eat good food, but decide not to. For a lot of these people, this IS a lifestyle choice. There is noway around that, and there would be no epidemic if this was confined to the "poor/rich" rhetoric.

Re:Our unrealistic views of death, through a doctor’s eyes by potatolicious on Monday February 20, 2012 @05:50AM (#3612013)
Here we go with the stereotyping again. The point you make has validity, but I simply cannot get behind it for the amount of stereotyping you are doing of the poor.

You are subscribing to the all-too-common "poor people with big screens and iPhones? What's that all about?" fallacy, except you ascribe even more universality to it than most.

> "People prefer spending their money on vacation, video games, buying the latest smartphone and so on"

This is a stereotype, unless you have convincing data to back it up. It is also about as offensive and useful as "black people! fried chicken! watermelons!"

See how far the conversation gets when this happens?

The "poor people are poor because they waste their money on lavish stupid spending" is a refrain we've heard way too many times. It's simply not true, fails to comprehend the complexity of the situation, and is frankly a complete moral cop-out.

I've had the fortunate/unfortunate experience of living on the wrong side of the tracks for part of my college years. I've lived with and befriended many of the people we upper-middles love to stereotype, victim-blame, and mock, and while there's always a sliver of truth to every stereotype, the characterization that the poor are poor, or that the poor are fat, because they're too stupid to act responsibly, is a pernicious and toxic lie.

Let's enumerate, for the record. You seem to believe that the poor:

- Spend their money on vacation, video games, and the latest smartphones instead of being smart about their finances.

- Need to watch 4 hours of "dumb TV shows" every night to be satisfied with their (presumably pathetic and meaningless) lives.

I honestly don't think we can have a discussion about the broader point of diet/obesity while you're chiseling at these points.

> "You cannot seriously tell me that 33% of the US is composed of poor people living in crime-ridden suburbs."

Have you been to the US lately? Despite what you might see in major cities or in the Valley, the majority of this country is poor as fuck. The notion that the vast majority of America enjoys a standard of living lightyears ahead of the rest of the world... is simply not true. Fully 42% of this country has an annual income of under $25,000.

The obesity epidemic in the USA is at its core tied to socioeconomic status. Hell, the fact that state-by-state obesity rates is highly correlated with state economic strength should be very telling.

Re:Our unrealistic views of death, through a doctor’s eyes by ekianjo on Monday February 20, 2012 @07:18PM (#3614554)
> The obesity epidemic in the USA is at its core tied to socioeconomic status. Hell, the fact that state-by-state obesity rates is highly correlated with state economic strength should be very telling.

You need to check your numbers, because that's not what studies are saying. http://frac.org/initiatives/hunger-and-obesity/are-low-incom...

Quote: "Among men, obesity rates were fairly similar across income groups, although they tended to be slightly higher at higher levels of income. In fact, among Black and Mexican-American men, those with higher income were significantly more likely to be obese than those with low-income."

Shocking, it says the exact opposite of what you were trying to prove. So there actually ARE people with higher income who are obese, it seems.

Re:Our unrealistic views of death, through a doctor’s eyes by jimrandomh on Monday February 20, 2012 @06:11PM (#3614370)
> No, I assure that even if you eat too much healthy food, you will grow fat and obese the same.

This isn't true. If you eat lots of healthy food, and get even a little bit of exercise, then you will gain weight, but it'll be muscle instead of fat. If you eat only a little, then you will lose weight, but the quality of what you do eat will determine whether the losses come from fat or from muscle.

> A number of these 33% HAVE the money, HAVE the time, HAVE the means to eat good food, but decide not to.

What has actually happened is that people decide to eat healthy, but society lies to them about what is and isn't healthy.

Re:Our unrealistic views of death, through a doctor’s eyes by ekianjo on Monday February 20, 2012 @07:15PM (#3614547)
> If you eat lots of healthy food, and get even a little bit of exercise, then you will gain weight, but it'll be muscle instead of fat.

Seriously, do you have anything to substantiate that claim? I have seen obese people even in countryside where they were eating nothing but so-called "healthy food". Since when "healthy food" becomes muscles ?