LLMs are not being sold as delivering only plausible language. Is it the craftsman's fault when the salesman lies?
I think you are barking up the wrong tree here. As much as I understand your scepticism, OpenAI have been very transparent about the limitations of GPT and it is not truthful to say otherwise.
In what limit does "apparently reasonable and credible" diverge from "true"?
We'd make the LLM not lie if we could. All this "plausible" language constitutes practitioner weasel words. We'd collectively love if the LLMs were more truthful than a 5-year-old.
From https://simonwillison.net/2023/May/27/lawyer-chatgpt/ (which has the dates)
> Mar 1st, 2023 is where things get interesting. This document was filed—“Affirmation in Opposition to Motion”—and it cites entirely fictional cases! One example quoted from that document (emphasis mine):
GPT-4 wasn't available until March 14th ( https://openai.com/research/gpt-4 ), so we're dealing with 3.5 here.
Where was 3.5 advertised to do more than generate plausible language in a conversation and who is making those claims?
GPT was not primarily made to produce factual statements. While factual accuracy certainly constitutes a desirable design aspiration, and undeniably makes the LLM more useful, it should not be expected. Automobile designers, for example, strive to ensure safety during high-speed collisions, a feature that almost invariably benefits the user. However, if someone uses their car to demolish their house, this is probably not going to leave them satisfied. And I don't think we can say the car is a lemon for this.