Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by nforgerit on Saturday May 27, 2023 @07:57AM
(#36093966)
Superfluous renewable energy already has to go to hydrolysis to produce hydrogen to be saved for times whenever renewables don't produce energy.
Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by boringg on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:03AM
(#36094010)
Actually battery storage and stored hydro work. As does long duration battery storage options that are in the works now.
Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by Sinidir on Saturday May 27, 2023 @10:44AM
(#36095221)
They don't work nearly as well enough or in the case of hydro storage are available in enough quantity to cover a month of weak wind.
For example. The US would consume its entirety of pumped hydro storage in a third of a day.
Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by oezi on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:03AM
(#36094013)
Superfluous energy should go to the consumer which otherwise would consume the most CO2. We do not need to use hydrogen when renewables aren't available (if such a situation should arise). We can continue to use fossils for these (rare) situations.
The only thing which matters is to use energy in the most CO2 efficient way to achieve goals overall.
Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by bradleyjg on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:03AM
(#36094006)
It’s hard for me to believe that the answer isn’t biological given the whole self replication thing.
Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by samatman on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:08AM
(#36094038)
The Industrial Revolution is a history of various industrial processes outcompeting biology within a narrow boundary. Cars pull more than any horse, trains as well, an airplane flies faster and with much more cargo than any bird, and the industrial production of nitrogen is faster than bat guano.
CO2 fixation might also follow this curve, in fact, as a technology in isolation that's what I would bet on. Economics aside, a machine that sucks CO2 directly out of the air will remove much more CO2 than the equivalent parcel of land would if biology were used.
Re:Direct air capture: our technology to capture CO₂
by bradleyjg on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:13AM
(#36094079)
As a technology in isolation, sure. But something like iron seeding, assuming it works, would be orders of magnitude cheaper because most of the work is being done by algae and they don’t have to be paid.
I don’t think horses are particularly similar, but nitrogen fixation in the fertilize vs crop rotation case gets closer.
I am no expert in the field, but this is an area that at least gives me some positive outlook on the future. I could imagine, for example, that we start over provisioning electricity with renewables; and instead of scaling them down when there is no energy demand, we will redirect the superfluous energy into carbon capture.