News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by joejohnson on Saturday February 18, 2012 @12:28PM (#3607068)
This "article" is BS. The average rating for Dream Heights on iTunes (at the time of my writing this) is above 4.5/5 stars. Hardly the overwhelming negative response this article claims.
Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by palish on Saturday February 18, 2012 @01:36PM (#3607276)
The game pops up a messagebox that says "If you give us 5 stars, we'll give you more features!"

Proof: http://db.tt/whiVaG0t

Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by abk on Saturday February 18, 2012 @01:38PM (#3607286)
Not a fan of zynga, but tiny tower and others do that too. It seems pretty standard for games to prompt users for reviews.
Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by palish on Saturday February 18, 2012 @01:43PM (#3607311)
They're offering additional game features in exchange for 5 stars, not merely prompting users for reviews.

Do other apps do this?

Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by joejohnson on Saturday February 18, 2012 @04:54PM (#3607855)
What are you quoting? The picture you post says "Give us a FIVE-STAR rating! Higher ratings mean more features!" I take this to mean they will develop their higher-rated games more than their lower-rated ones. Where does it say you can have more features in exchange for a high rating?
Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by MrFoof on Saturday February 18, 2012 @12:54PM (#3607152)
I agree with the headline being sensationalized.

However, the default iTunes sort method will still manage to do some damage. If I recall correctly, iTunes sorts reviews mostly by how many people found it helpful. Additionally, this is as an absolute value, not a percentage (so 8 of 65 finding helpful will be above one that 7 of 7 found helpful). The result is if you go to the App Store page, the reviews you are shown by default -- overall rating aside -- are all heavily-upvoted one-star reviews.

The question that's left is how much of a material effect the one-star reviews being shown by default are having on the game's sales. However, even if there is no material effect, that's probably not a black mark Zynga wants visible even if it's not affecting sales much (or at all).

The "Whose Expression is it Anyways?" article on Gamasutra (link: http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/TommyWu/20120216/9455/Whose_E...) I think is a good discussion on the topic. Using that article's terms, Dream Heights may only be the "legal distance" from Tiny Tower's design, instead of the "classy distance".

Re:'Tiny Tower' Ripoff 'Dream Heights' Hits US App Store; Zy... by tzs on Saturday February 18, 2012 @01:41PM (#3607303)
You've confused ratings and reviews.