News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SCOTUS Declines to Hear Challenge to Warrantless Pole Cam... by giraffe_lady on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:34AM (#36059553)
No I'm just trying to avoid that classic HN situation of being talked into making specific assertions outside my expertise and then technical flaws being used to dismiss the broader point I'm making.

Writing good laws is hard sure but you're approaching this having already accepted the framing that the only way to prevent this police overreach is to restrict everyone from doing similar things. We can just prevent the police from doing this. We don't need to write a perfectly generalizable restriction on everyone's ability to take pictures or whatever. The cops aren't the public and should be subject to additional restrictions beyond what the public is subjected to.

Re:SCOTUS Declines to Hear Challenge to Warrantless Pole Cam... by Clubber on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:48AM (#36059753)
>having already accepted the framing that the only way to prevent this police overreach is to restrict everyone from doing similar things.

My position is people should be free to photograph in public anything they can see. That's currently how the law is written. I don't think it's perfect, but I can't think of a better alternative (thus this discussion).

>The cops aren't the public and should be subject to additional restrictions beyond what the public is subjected to.

I agree as an ideal, but in practice there are a lot of barriers.

  - They can legally arrest you, even if you didn't break any laws and aren't required to even know the law.
  - They aren't legally required to help anybody.
  - They have blanket qualified immunity granted by the SCOTUS.
  - Each police department and sheriff's department is their own jurisdiction, so any blanket restraint would need to be done at the federal level.
  - They have one of, if not the strongest unions in the country.
  - They have strong political support that is just now eroding a bit in blue states.
We are having a hard time just managing police brutality and unnecessary force currently.
Re:SCOTUS Declines to Hear Challenge to Warrantless Pole Cam... by giraffe_lady on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:58AM (#36059927)
Yeah I mean yes this is a small & compromised step on the path towards the necessary goal of completely eliminating the police. They are wholly incompatible with any conception of freedom or justice.