News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You don't need a modal window by ebiester on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @08:42AM (#36057214)
Wrong use case. Think more like a web application where a modal comes up for more details and to edit details instead of going to a separate page and URL.
Re:You don't need a modal window by layer8 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:16AM (#36057582)
You are describing the cases I hate, because you then can't (easily) open those views in a separate window while keeping the current view for reference.

It's similarly annoying as paging controls that don't support "open in new window" and/or don't work with the browser history.

Re:You don't need a modal window by smeagull on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:41AM (#36057923)
You mean like a web application where the modal edit window blocks the information on the original page that I would want to refer to, so I have to close the window, copy it in to a text editor, and bring back the modal window?

Sounds wonderful.

Re:You don't need a modal window by jen20 on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:18AM (#36057613)
It’s the same use case. The browser is an agent of the user, not of the website developer.
Re:You don't need a modal window by jevgeni on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @09:52AM (#36058078)
It's not the wrong use case. I need you guys developing apps to listen:

- I *want* more details on a separate, linkable URL.

- I *want* it to open in either the same window, or a separate window if I ctrl+click it.

"Subscribe to newsletter" use case is just the worst use case.

Re:You don't need a modal window by ebiester on Wednesday May 24, 2023 @11:02AM (#36059095)
Us "developing apps" aren't the ones designing modals - there are teams doing that instead and we implement what they suggest. It turns out that when they ask users of the software I build, at least, that this isn't a common complaint.

The problem that designers are often trying to solve is that there is not enough information that there is a good way to put it on its own page - it's too small for its own page but too large for the table that we'd rather just add another column to.

We have an export button so you can get all the details in excel or LibreOffice or your tool of choice, though. And in a better world, we'd be writing proper desktop apps instead of web applications so that we aren't making stupid compromises like this, but here we are.