Re:Essential JavaScript Design Patterns For Beginners
by danso on Friday February 17, 2012 @02:28PM
(#3604627)
On just length alone, if this is the beginner's version, would love to see the intermediate/advanced versions ;)
I like the references to Backbone.js and other modern frameworks...the explanation of Backbone's router vs Spine's controller was particularly helpful, mostly because I know Backbone's router is not a controller but hadn't taken the time to see how Spine does it.
I thought the introduction...everything before the actual examples/cases, was a little too long-winded for me. It was interesting to read as an experienced programmer, but I can't imagine a beginner trudging through all of that without seeing a simplified use case to break up the long narrative text. If the audience for this book is beginners, why go into such great detail about the philosophy of patterns (including a discussion of antipatterns) when most beginners are at the level where they probably don't know much OOP or even things like closures?
Otherwise, another fantastic addition to the open-source bookshelf.
I like the references to Backbone.js and other modern frameworks...the explanation of Backbone's router vs Spine's controller was particularly helpful, mostly because I know Backbone's router is not a controller but hadn't taken the time to see how Spine does it.
I thought the introduction...everything before the actual examples/cases, was a little too long-winded for me. It was interesting to read as an experienced programmer, but I can't imagine a beginner trudging through all of that without seeing a simplified use case to break up the long narrative text. If the audience for this book is beginners, why go into such great detail about the philosophy of patterns (including a discussion of antipatterns) when most beginners are at the level where they probably don't know much OOP or even things like closures?
Otherwise, another fantastic addition to the open-source bookshelf.