Re:Hacking Hacker News
by underwater on Friday February 17, 2012 @12:19PM
(#3604086)
I remember there being a lot of discussion before subreddits where most people (myself included) wanted tagging instead of subdomains. The subreddits have obviously worked well but I think they (along with self posts and image previews) also changed reddit from a news aggregator into a glorified forum.
My theory is that as communities grow, you have one of two choices to maintain cohesion: aggressively police who is let in or give people with divergent interests space to express those interests.
If you don't, and your community is growing, eventually the most valuable members will no longer find value in the community. This is just reversion to the mean. But the consequence is that those valuable people will then leave, and the cycle repeats until the community evaporates entirely.
Subreddits are a "pressure valve" that allow high-value users to self-select and maintain their own set of norms without sacrificing the growth of the main public square.
It's not the stories and comments that are fundamentally valuable to HN, it's the people.