News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by josephcsible on Monday May 22, 2023 @05:23PM (#36036910)
I don't consider it "being monitored" when the person you're talking to is the one doing the recording. Contrast "I'm legally allowed to keep emails sent to me after I first read them" with "other people are legally allowed to read emails sent to me". Wouldn't almost everyone agree that the former is a good thing but the latter would be a bad thing?
Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by JumpCrisscross on Monday May 22, 2023 @05:34PM (#36037005)
> don't consider it "being monitored" when the person you're talking to is the one doing the recording

Compromise is reached in quiet, safe places. Politicians make bombastic statements for their base and donors, and then go behind closed doors to negotiate. You can't negotiate in earnest if every offer for compromise you put forward immediately results in (a) the losers of that compromise creating a ruckus and (b) your opponent using (a) to weaken you.

Public negotiations reward playing to the audience. (You see this in small groups–letting leaders or the people in a friend group who disagree pull aside almost always solves the problem better than litigating it as a group.) If every conversation might be recorded for replaying to a third party, then every conversation will be treated as an open one. That destroys room for compromise.

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by autoexec on Monday May 22, 2023 @05:59PM (#36037241)
This seems like a weak argument since compromise may be more difficult, but it certainly isn't impossible when conversations are transparent. Eventually the "losers" of a compromise are going to learn about how their elected officials voted and what the impact of that vote will be for them, and they'll hold their elected officials accountable for it regardless.

It just isn't worth forcing every person to give up the ability to protect themselves by recording their everyday conversations just so that politicians can lie to the public and their donors while screwing over the people behind closed doors.

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by JumpCrisscross on Monday May 22, 2023 @06:32PM (#36037530)
Legislative deliberation, i.e. hashing out details, should be open [1]. At the bargaining phase, when you're working out high-level frameworks, the theory says closed doors win [2]. (Put another way, in a transparent bargaining environment, the winning move is to ignore your opponent and beat your drums to your base.)

> Eventually the "losers" of a compromise are going to learn about how their elected officials voted

The point is to let both sides table ideas without having to face the downside. To propose what if scenarios to the other side.

[1] https://preprints.apsanet.org/engage/api-gateway/apsa/assets...

[2] https://eprints.lse.ac.uk/225/1/open-door8.pdf

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by the8472 on Monday May 22, 2023 @06:37PM (#36037578)
That cuts two ways. If everything they said was on the record there would be no point in putting on a show since it will immediately turn out the show is all fake.

Imagine if politicians acted like normal people, negotiating things in nuance instead of being showmen.

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by JumpCrisscross on Monday May 22, 2023 @06:50PM (#36037688)
> If everything they said was on the record there would be no point in putting on a show since it will immediately turn out the show is all fake

Then they never turn off. We're seeing this in a new breed of popular, partisan and policy-wise useless politicians. Unsurprisingly, they don't get invited to consequential meetings, because the moment someone suggests giving pound of flesh on their side in exchange for the other side conceding in part, a tweet goes out about how the first person sold out or blinked or whatnot.

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by jltsiren on Monday May 22, 2023 @06:51PM (#36037705)
Don't blame the politicians. Blame the people who have opinions. The public debate is so dominated by bad-faith arguments that it's not productive to treat it as a real debate. Until the social consequences of arguing in bad faith are severe enough, all meaningful political discussion must happen off the record.
Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by nordsieck on Monday May 22, 2023 @07:05PM (#36037827)
> Compromise is reached in quiet, safe places. Politicians make bombastic statements for their base and donors, and then go behind closed doors to negotiate.

That may be. But corruption also festers in quiet safe places. It's not clear to me that the the tradeoff is worth it.

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by JumpCrisscross on Monday May 22, 2023 @07:44PM (#36038110)
> corruption also festers in quiet safe places. It's not clear to me that the the tradeoff is worth it.

Public legislating, private bargaining [1]. This keeps substantive deliberation in the public domain while the horse trading, the job republics delegate to elected representatives, has a limited space within which it can efficiently engage.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36037530

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by dabluecaboose on Monday May 22, 2023 @05:44PM (#36037096)
Okay, fair enough. I was so focused on my own perception of privacy that it hadn't occurred to me that the person I'm talking to has every right to record the conversation just as much as they do to remember it.

Speaking as someone who often has to tell people "Email that to me or I won't remember it", I can see the utility without it being intrusive.

Re:Leaked government document shows Spain wants to ban end-t... by hunter2_ on Monday May 22, 2023 @07:48PM (#36038148)
The main difference is that if they remember it and tell someone else, it's hearsay, but if they record it and play it for someone else, it's evidence. At least until deepfakes ruin that idea and make the two equivalently refutable.