News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A digital payments revolution in India by tecoholic on Saturday May 20, 2023 @08:36PM (#36016899)
The UPI and its proliferation has been useful. No doubt.

But I am really stumped by the people who claim it’s a revolution because they could now pay street vendors, rural road side shops…etc., Correct me if I am wrong, one could do that with cash right? It doesn’t require electricity and a working internet connection, the merchant doesn’t have to go to a bank to get the cash? Also why is bringing millions of Indians into banking system always consider a good thing? In the rural areas people (esp women who depend on govt programs like rural employment scheme, self help groups..etc.,) spend an entire day organising themselves to visit the bank that’s usually a couple of KMs away, spend the day waiting in queue because women from 5 other villages are also there to get their money. The banking system inclusion has helps the technocrats who helps sell these systems to collect data, build financial profiles and sell it to the govt or credit agencies, but has not made people’s lives better necessarily.

No, the public sector banks don’t always provide ATM cards, there is also fingerprint auth required for some accounts so they have to go in person, sometimes people just lose their cards and don’t get new ones for whatever reason.

Now you might be thinking, UPI solves all of these issues. But the issues were created by the same technocrats who wanted everyone to be in the banking system in the first place.

I add this comment not as a criticism for UPI, but as a reality check on the revolutionary nature of these technological solutions.

There are no comments on this comment yet.