Re:US Supreme Court leaves protections for internet companie...
by jaredklewis on Friday May 19, 2023 @07:15PM
(#36007885)
I don't think that's a loophole. On the contrary, if 230 were reinterpreted to mean that online content providers were legally required to have no editorial control over use provided content, that would be a pretty significant departure from current case law.
Section 230 is quite short and (to my mind) somewhat vague, which I think lends itself to different understandings. But I don't think it could be reasonably interpreted to mean that online publishers cannot moderate user content as they see fit.
Re:US Supreme Court leaves protections for internet companie...
by 1lint on Friday May 19, 2023 @08:01PM
(#36008151)
I think you are responding to the wrong comment, or putting words in my mouth.
I didn't write Section 230 should be reinterpreted "to mean that online content providers were legally required to have no editorial control over use provided content" as you say, or even advocate for any reinterpretation of Section 230.
Loopholes in the law should be fixed by the legislature, not by misinterpreting the law as it is written.
For example if a hypothetical billionaire acquirer of a social media site wanted to (implicitly) promote a cryptocurrency project, he could shadowban negative comments against the project, leaving comments in favor of the project to dominate on the site. At the same time, Section 230 would still shield his company from liability for those comments in favor of the project. This creates a situation in which the social media is in essence promoting the project, but in a roundabout way that shields them from liability. I can see this being especially problematic as it is applied to influencing elections.
In my opinion, Section 230 protections should come with some obligation to respect the principles of free speech.