Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by MichaelZuo on Friday May 19, 2023 @09:09AM
(#36001477)
I wonder if that's inflation adjusted or not, because I can easily imagine that after factoring in inflation the depreciated value of a 30 year old weapon system is about the same as the new price 30 years ago.
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by 0xcde4c3db on Friday May 19, 2023 @09:29AM
(#36001689)
I'm not an accountant, and I don't know how the Pentagon approaches depreciation schedules, but most examples I've seen in general descriptions have annualized rates much higher than inflation. Also, some methods have a final period over which the the depreciation is 100% of the remaining value, which can't be offset by any amount of inflation.
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by someotherperson on Friday May 19, 2023 @10:42AM
(#36002559)
Not an accountant, might have issues:
There are depreciation schedules in taxation that let you offset your tax. To this effect, 100% depreciation would expense the item (and thus reduce the taxable income). Because the tax doesn't represent 100% of the value you paid for the item, it doesn't mean that the item no longer with value.
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by whinenot on Friday May 19, 2023 @11:51AM
(#36003369)
Scrap has storage and disposal costs, especially for things that go boom. Giving old war machines and ordnance away is probably a huge expense reduction for all NATO donor countries.
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by blitzar on Friday May 19, 2023 @11:52AM
(#36003381)
I thought this was the idea all along... the announcements were all using as new sticker prices +r&d for the first manufacturing run on 20 year old hardware, it was a feature not a bug.
Cynically this "accounting error" is either an excuse to send more hardware to achive the same absolute $$ cost, or a method of communicating that the "cost" to the taxpayer was much (much much) lower than it really was.
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by lookboil on Friday May 19, 2023 @09:45AM
(#36001882)
I'm old enough to remember the $2 trillion Pentagon accounting error announced by Rumsfeld the day before 9/11. Didn't hear much about that in the intervening years
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by snapcaster on Friday May 19, 2023 @10:39AM
(#36002527)
Not very satisfying debunking, $2.3 trillion being untrackable implies many billions being stolen. Don't really think it had much to do with 9/11, just a huge fucking grift on the taxpayers
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by djfobbz on Friday May 19, 2023 @11:29AM
(#36003104)
Fact checkers always make me chuckle! Have you ever wondered where the fact checkers themselves comes from? Also, what is their vested interest in fact checking? Nothing comes free!
Re:$3B accounting error by The Pentagon
by ROTMetro on Friday May 19, 2023 @12:52PM
(#36004092)
I too when presented with facts think to myself 'but who is the person who typed these all out'. Do you have anything specific about these facts that you disagree with, or are you just spreading FUD to spread FUD? Did you eat up all the Microsoft FUD around Linux in the past too?
There are depreciation schedules in taxation that let you offset your tax. To this effect, 100% depreciation would expense the item (and thus reduce the taxable income). Because the tax doesn't represent 100% of the value you paid for the item, it doesn't mean that the item no longer with value.
You don't want to sell working explosives (or, nukes) to random scrap yards but make sure they aren't working.
Cynically this "accounting error" is either an excuse to send more hardware to achive the same absolute $$ cost, or a method of communicating that the "cost" to the taxpayer was much (much much) lower than it really was.
Hopefully this is the explanation.