Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by zzzmarcus on Monday November 10, 2008 @05:56PM
(#359881)
By your logic, stating the obvious fact that there are differences between races makes you a racist.
There are differences between the races and some do stem from environmental factors, a fact that is well documented and is part of the theory of evolution and natural selection.
It's ridiculous to call Gladwell a racist for pointing out one of those differences and theorize on its cause.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by unalone on Monday November 10, 2008 @05:59PM
(#359884)
My good-at-math friend is Asian, and her parents instilled a very powerful work ethic in her. That's not racism. It's a cultural difference.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by thomasmallen on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:03PM
(#359890)
What you've said is 100% correct. Notice how you didn't attribute it to a history of rice farming, but rather to academic prowess and diligence.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by unalone on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:06PM
(#359896)
I think you're associating two things that Gladwell didn't. He brings up rice farming for the anecdote about fallow-fields versus 360-days-of-work.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by thomasmallen on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:09PM
(#359901)
In that case I was wrong to trust the article linked here.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by unalone on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:10PM
(#359908)
Yeah. It's a pretty bad one.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by thomasmallen on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:14PM
(#359914)
I just remembered that I read "Tipping Point" years ago and didn't detect any prejudice or really any negativity. I just didn't put two and two together (Gladwell's name doesn't stand out to me).
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by SkylerNovak on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:16PM
(#359916)
The article is good. Just look a the discussion it's begun.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by unalone on Monday November 10, 2008 @06:19PM
(#359922)
But the discussion exists because the topic is so vivid. The article itself is rambling, incoherent, and at many times wrong.
Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by time_management on Monday November 10, 2008 @07:25PM
(#360002)
It's not a theory he came up with, that Asian cultures tend to have stronger and more rigid work ethics because rice is labor-intensive, whereas Europeans tend to seek clever ways of eliminating work because the farming of traditional European grains is capital-intensive. I don't buy it, but it's not a crack theory and Gladwell isn't the first to propose it.
"And then there are the math geniuses who, as anyone can’t help noticing, are disproportionately Asian. Citing the work of an educational researcher at the University of Pennsylvania, Gladwell attributes this phenomenon not to some innate mathematical ability that Asians possess but to the fact that children in Asian countries are willing to work longer and harder than their Western counterparts. That willingness, Gladwell continues, is due to a cultural legacy of hard work that stems from the cultivation of rice."
That's right up there with claiming that Africans and African Americans excel at athletics because they purportedly once chased or were chased by wild animals: Patronizing and offensive to the extreme. People in entertainment have lost their careers for saying such things.