Re:Elizabeth Holmes is going to prison – with a $500M bill
by ak_111 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:19AM
(#35984961)
I sympathise with this view in general and with her situation having kids she won't be able to see for 10 years.
But us I understand in this specific case she played an important role in driving one of her employees to suicide, and her fraud concerning her tech is not just financial, it was giving people false information about their health, including cancer - which is close to violence to me.
In fact my sympathy with this case is not that it is too harsh for a small crime (fraud), it is that the crime is so huge that she must have been psychopath and might deserve mental treatment. Genuinely how can someone live with giving hundred of thousands of people false health information based on a test they know is garbage?
Re:Elizabeth Holmes is going to prison – with a $500M bill
by agentgumshoe on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:06AM
(#35984898)
So what consequences do you propose for those that create such frauds that should act as an effective deterrent? Being 'demoted' after the fact doesn't really encourage anyone not to get to the top and do fraud in the first place.
Re:Elizabeth Holmes is going to prison – with a $500M bill
by dataengineer56 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:37AM
(#35985048)
She is dangerous to other people. Let's not forget that this was medical fraud - people's lives were affected due to bad diagnoses.
Re:Elizabeth Holmes is going to prison – with a $500M bill
by Daub on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:54AM
(#35985152)
> I think only people who are violent and dangerous to other people should be locked up, and even then only until they are no longer dangerous.
What about people who knowingly allow the blood of cancer patents to be tested using technology which they know does not work?
Re:Elizabeth Holmes is going to prison – with a $500M bill
by failbuffer on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:15AM
(#35986056)
You're discounting the deterrent effect. Defrauding investors has a huge negative impact on society, to say nothing of bogus blood test results, deceiving regulators, and ruthlessly threatening legal actions against whistleblowers and journalists.
If things can be organised so she is no longer capable of defrauding people (banned from holding certain positions in companies etc.) I don't see why she should be locked up.
I'm sure I would feel differently if I had been defrauded by her, but isn't that exactly why the burden of justice fulls on people other than the aggrieved?