Re:Malcolm Gladwell versus Ayn Rand: Who is right?
by unalone on Tuesday November 11, 2008 @04:16PM
(#360976)
Rand is very dogmatic, unfortunately. I like her ideas more than I do her execution of them.
Gladwell takes it a bit too far, in my opinion. The NYmag was the first interview I read of his, and he seems too determined to avoid taking the credit. It doesn't make him evil per se, not like Rand would say, but it does annoy me when I read his interview.
Malcolm Gladwell and Ayn Rand are both wrong.
Contra Gladwell, most great successes have great ability; they succeed where mediocrities would fail. Contra Rand, most great successes have great luck; they succeed where the unlucky would fail.
Indeed, if both ability and luck are major factors in success, the truly great are those who are both lucky and good. This leads to what I immodestly term Hartl's Law:
Since great success requires great luck, everyone great is overrated.
This includes, by the way, both Gladwell and Rand---as, I suspect, Gladwell would readily concede, but Rand (were she alive) would surely not.