> The best hires I've seen in my life have come through word of mouth referrals. No data, no recruiters, no leetcode, no HR screenings.
Nepotism. It gets a lot of bad rap but the reason this is effective is because you're essentially comparing hiring via a piece of paper vs via intimate knowledge of a candidate's actual knowledge and work habits. The latter clearly has more information than you could get from any screening process. Of course this doesn't mean you should just hire someone because they're a relative or friend because that's not actually using the information gain. But we should recognize why the process is successful. If we want to make a fair system that doesn't rely on nepotism then we have to also recognize why it works in the first place. I don't see these complicated hiring processes doing this.
Of course, you can also just use a noisy process. But if you're going to use a noisy process maybe don't make it so expensive (for company and candidate; money and time). If this is the method, then the process should be about minimizing the complexity and costs of hiring.
Nepotism. It gets a lot of bad rap but the reason this is effective is because you're essentially comparing hiring via a piece of paper vs via intimate knowledge of a candidate's actual knowledge and work habits. The latter clearly has more information than you could get from any screening process. Of course this doesn't mean you should just hire someone because they're a relative or friend because that's not actually using the information gain. But we should recognize why the process is successful. If we want to make a fair system that doesn't rely on nepotism then we have to also recognize why it works in the first place. I don't see these complicated hiring processes doing this.
Of course, you can also just use a noisy process. But if you're going to use a noisy process maybe don't make it so expensive (for company and candidate; money and time). If this is the method, then the process should be about minimizing the complexity and costs of hiring.