"If I jiggle this is behaves differently" is like... half of all science!
At the end of the day, better is better, and I don't think that can be hand-waved away.
That's like saying someone is not smarter because they just "studied harder" and that doesn't count somehow.
"Let's publish a bunch of measurements we took" might be rigorous and look like what advancing science would look like if you squint. But this is just gaming the publishing game.
A lot of science is just taking down measurements and recording the result.
It's not always a giant leap, some grand insight, or a world-changing theorem.
The busywork in between might have looked like science and occupied a lot of time and space. Relativity and quantum mechanics generated a lot of falsifiable claims that were eventually tested. Yet we have been building larger and larger colliders to "collect and publish data" and the best outcome so far has been a job program for engineers (useful and good) and the Web (useful and good). But we shouldn't confuse collecting data and engineering with advancing science.