It’s not just Androids. In another book he comes up with this fascinating idea of an alternate history where Japan and Germany won WWII. And then it turns out astrology is real and everyone is obsessing over it. Just why?
I’m sure everyone will say actually astrology is fascinating, or you need to look past that to get the real meaning of the book. But I prefer the books that don’t meander into meaningless dead ends. There are plenty of them out there.
Yet others may say Dick was enormously influential and inspired many other brilliant authors. Ok, I’ll read those authors then.
Overall I’d rate the books I’ve read by Dick as 2 stars. And only because the premises are so fantastic.
Dick was always obsessed with a few core themes ("what is real?", "what is human?") plus a ton of personal and psychological issues. It was always erratic in his production, and while I like his works, I would generally agree that the way he developed his own premises could often be "disappointing" at least in the case of novels.
Short stories are usually much better, IMHO.
---
[1] here is my take on it, if you want to know a bit more about I-Ching: https://pa-mar.net/Lifestyle/I-Ching.html
Though I'm a huge fan of PKD, I didn't like DADOES either, and consider it to be one of his minor works. The movie was far better.
His top-tier works, in my view, are:
- Ubik
- The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch
- Martian Timeslip
Also, it’s interesting that in 2023, we can reasonably definitively answer that question for any definition of “dream”.