Re:We Don't Know How to Compute (2011) [video]
by marcosdumay on Monday May 15, 2023 @10:14PM
(#35957092)
Yeah, that's because you decided it should be a hand-coded expert system. If you review the set of hand-coded neural networks, you will discover they even more bloated, and have an extreme low ceiling on usefulness.
Besides, keep in mind that the currently useful NNs are stuff that requires dozens of GB of memory to run.
Anyway, training a NN is also an attempt to codify what symbols we see on the world.
Re:We Don't Know How to Compute (2011) [video]
by leroy-is-here on Tuesday May 16, 2023 @07:13AM
(#35960182)
I’m not sure I understand your point at all. Of course I decided what I wrote — I wrote it. Of course training some AI is an attempt to codify the world, that’s the point.
My entire premise was about an _if_ between hand-coded logic and probabilistic training. Hand coding the logical internals of a neural network is one marriage, but there could be others.
We as humans have the intelligence to simply see for fractions of a second and then just know — we can know the answers to math problems and how a person is feeling. The symbolic AI programming was an attempt to codify what symbols we are seeing but they are so diverse and nuanced it became apparent this was an ineffective scientific route.