It's precisely how content for encyclopedias are generally created. Encyclopedias are compilations and summaries of information about a variety of topics, not compilations of original research by experts from a variety of fields.
Yahoo tried to replicate business directories on and for the web, Google did not.
An encyclopedia is more like a dictionary. I cannot just add a word to a dictionary just because my colleagues and me thinks its a great word and we use it often or because we are great in our own field.
But what you have quoted is a nutshell summary. I can see how one reading of it could be that newspapers are always a reliable source (and as tabloids are a form of newspaper). But I have feeling you've seriously stretched the reading to prove a point.
Reliable sourcing is linked; and if you read that policy it will make it more clear.
FWIW I never like labelling sources, as some editors tend to, in certain categories (newspaper, journal, etc.) because our policy explicitly sets out criteria to apply to sources on an individual basis.
So in that respect, I agree with you that the nutshell is a problem.
Many of my articles have been shot down on Wikipedia along the same lines, until I no longer cared.
I do think that there is some merit to his defense (if there's not enough references or the references aren't really about the topic at hand...) but I think the balance would be better left with leaving the article in place and sticking the 'references aren't great quality, please improve' banner at the top.
Wikipedia will die because noone real can contribute. Write a new article and it will be shot down. Write an article about important programming languages and it will be killed with some strange acronym.
Exception: a several thousand word article about what Homer did eat in one 8 year old Simpson episode will stay.
"Programming languages are being deleted from Wikipedia " http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2215168
His “on the list” idea is totally Wikipedia directorate style and a.) will be implemented b.) will accelerate stagnation
Wikipedia will stay relevant - and I still use it - for some trivia I want to know, it's usually sufficient complete there. But it creates a mirror universe that reflects the thoughts of all editors, not of the online community.