News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by necovek on Saturday May 13, 2023 @11:04AM (#35929065)
But it is legal.

The obligation is on the reviewer to highlight they've been paid for a review, otherwise they are illegally misleading their readers.

Whether that's moral is another thing.

Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by orra on Saturday May 13, 2023 @11:13AM (#35929141)
You're right that paid reviews may be legal if they're clearly advertised as adverts, as opposed to framed as impartial reviews. But walking that line is fine, right, because people expect reviews to be impartial.

Regardless, the legal obligation[1] to transparently advertise this is on the firm, not (just) the bought reviewer. IIRC the Advertising Standards Authority recently had a case on a social media paid promotion, which reinforced this. Regardless, IMO the statute is quite clear the obligation is on the firm.

[1] https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2008/1277/part/2/made

Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by jeroenhd on Saturday May 13, 2023 @11:14AM (#35929158)
I'm not so sure about that:

> Don’t commission third parties to write fake reviews – you may be liable for their actions

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/online-reviews-an...

With proper disclosure there may be some leeway, but I wouldn't just assume paying someone for a fake review is legal. UK advertising laws can be very strict in some cases (and rightfully so, in my opinion).

Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by CWuestefeld on Saturday May 13, 2023 @11:49AM (#35929527)
I don't know UK law, but at least in the US, there's a clear difference between "illegal" and "liable". There's a lot of stuff that's perfectly legal, but that I may be liable for.
Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by bgidley on Saturday May 13, 2023 @11:11AM (#35929129)
It may not be legal depending on how it’s done - this was Asus UK and the rules are on https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/online-reviews-an...

The UK Government are also in processing tightening this up…

Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by c0m on Saturday May 13, 2023 @11:26AM (#35929278)
I suspect the CSA’s new ‘rip-off tip-off’ campaign would be interested in this!

https://ripoff-tipoff.campaign.gov.uk/

Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by gnopgnip on Saturday May 13, 2023 @12:21PM (#35929862)
Almost all new car reviews are paid. It often includes flying reviewers out and paying $500+ a night for their hotel
Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by clnq on Saturday May 13, 2023 @12:31PM (#35929969)
Exactly. They completely missed the point that it’s unethical and immoral.

But we accept a lot of this legal and immoral behaviour for money. Predatory lending, price gouging, tax avoidance, factory animal farming, hustle culture employee exploitation, environmental negligence, data mining and privacy invasion, lobbying for self-interest, and so on and on. All completely normal from the perspective of hardcore capitalism. All immoral when looked at any other way.

Asus is perhaps saying more to us than we are willing to hear. Like for many successful corporations in capitalist terms (valuable in net worth, having had produced significant capital growth/gains), morality is not a real obstacle to their function — can be totally brushed aside.

It’s time we hold them accountable, because we have failed to do so with so many other unethical business models. If we don’t, more than just some burnt chips are at stake.

Re:Asus UK PR believes it is ‘legal to buy positive reviews’ by mrweasel on Saturday May 13, 2023 @01:37PM (#35930675)
It's just always surprising when companies think that legality and morality are the same thing. Either they didn't expect to get caught, or they see nothing wrong with it, that latter being worse.

The majority of companies that gets punished by consumers these days seem to me to be those who think that just because something is legal, then it's without consequences.