"Transformers are GNNs (somewhat trivial ones, as they are sheaf NNs, but nonetheless) and GNNs are dynamic programmers, which has been shown via category theory (Velolickovic etc al)."
In which paper did Velolickovic demonstrate this?
It's literally the title. Peter Velockovic is probably the most prolific author of this era regarding LLMs, and does not yet realize it. https://arxiv.org/pdf/2203.15544.pdf
Anyway, if you do actually know about NLP, I would highly suggest looking at some of the recent work in GNNs (and obviously of Viswani 2017, etc - but you should've gotten that through hype). Transformers are GNNs (somewhat trivial ones, as they are sheaf NNs, but nonetheless) and GNNs are dynamic programmers, which has been shown via category theory (Velolickovic etc al). Hence, GNNs align with algorithmic reasoning, so in a way there is a proof already in the papers mentioned that these systems do reason (there's several, which are easy to find given what I've mentioned). Also, a group in Microsoft has a working on arxiv detailing the many different types of reasoning there are, and how GPT4 does on each type - spoiler - it's for the most part >80% on all the benchmarks, and does only about 6% lower than humans.
So all in all, your claims aren't really supported. If you want to hold the same sentiment of your statement though, you could say we're asking the wrong questions. That's probably true somehow, and will probably be where people will retreat to / move goal posts on next.