Agreed too that my office lease is about the same number of pages as a typical residential contract, but far more dense. My landlord added some of the most ridiculous clauses I've ever seen in any contract - and prior to real estate, I regularly wrote business contracts from scratch.
You’re in the business so this might seen brash but it’s not meant to be. I’m just a pretty experienced buyer/seller.
The assumption I have to make is 1) buyer couldn’t have negotiated that themselves (I happen to be a good negotiator) and 2) further negotiated to keep the buyer’s agent portion of the commission (it’s a standard seller’s cost they’ve already agreed to pay so doesn’t matter if it goes to me or to an agent, net to seller is the same). I’ve done both, regularly. It’s not for everyone for sure, negotiating skills are the hardest to screen for when I have used agents but people not knowing how to negotiate should definitely focus on trying to find that skillset. But saving more than you cost someone is good, but not guaranteed and it’s always possible to pocket the fee you do charge; so you still have a cost and I usually have to decide if “you’re” worth it for something I can do over a handful of calls/emails.
Also I’m a landlord and those contracts like you said are much more dense. Where I am, the standard sales contracts change annually but not significantly in the last 15 years anyway. For example, I’ve noticed they’ve recently done away with the X days after in favor of precise dates. The math involved in X days and then finding later it lands on a Sunday or something was always sloppy IMO so I welcomed this change. But anyway, the fact it’s focused on a sale makes it so much easier to read than a lease which specifies so much more about condition, use, pets, roommates, etc.
Where I work, there's added complexity to the market in part by the variety of properties and the shortage of skilled agents. Of the licensed agents in the area, only about 30% are actually "full-time" agents, and of that 30% very few will do much outside standard residential work - and we've got several types of specialty agriculture, bare land, commercial, and we are on a state line. Our forms in both states have been going through a surprising amount of volatility the past few years, as have what I'll call "practices", Ie: what's considered normal buyer / seller responsibilities and negotiating chips. For example - with one of these practices I saw a way that our area was behind the times, I started doing things differently and it put my clients in a negotiating position such that my sellers were getting a much higher return relative to comparable properties.
I agree on negotiating skills - unfortunately, the public seem to pick agents based on who they know socially rather than on professional abilities. Finally, to your point about negotiating - one of the challenges for many buyers (and sellers) is that they really don't know the value of a property or where it should sell. So for example many buyers (assuming they aren't in a competitive situation - in which case it's a different set of strategies) will offer some stupidly low number in hopes to get the seller to come back with a reduced price. It's "let's split the difference" negotiating, rather than a data-driven approach. So for example when we go into a negotiation, we don't just index off of the asking price, but rather we've done a market analysis (as a example) of our own and thus have arrived at what we believe to be the fair market price. From that, anything below that number is gravy. So when I not only negotiate below the asking price, but below where we believe the property should fairly sell, then we've really won for the client. Or likewise when I'm on the sellers side, there's a whole slew of ways I set us up pre-market to put us in the best possible position. Even knowing how to read the possibly negotiating strategies for a property, or what "levers and dials" are available in a negotiation isn't something that the general public understands - if you've done a number of deals on your own, you may have developed this expertise.
FWIW: In one of the states where I do business, it is about to become law that we have to have these with clients. I expect it to be a total clusterfuck.
Requiring it to show, seems like a mess that will slow things down or people will just ignore it/backdate it like they do so much already to beautify things for underwriters and such.
I have to get creative to get the commission into my pocket when I don't use agents. First, the other side usually does have an agent and explaining to them that I want the commission and it's already a sunk cost is usually a nightmare. I do it at the end, because otherwise it impacts negotiations "but your keeping the commissions already". (No I'm talking to you, doing the work of an agent, so I should get paid just like you are; it doesn't cost your seller anything more than the transaction costs they were already planning - in reality, I know it's because the sell side hears no agent and thinks "I get to keep it all").
In my state, it says only licensed RE brokers and attorneys can collect commissions. I'm neither. But we also have a clause in the law that allows commission rebates. So, I typically just pay an attorney a small flat fee to collect the commission and rebate it back to me. It can be a pain but then I realized I don't have to tell the sell side anything, I now have a standing agreement with my attorney who will collect the buy side commission and subtract out the flat fee part and rebate the rest to me. I just put his info on the offer as my agent and give him a heads up a few days before close. It works pretty well.
Essentially - I expect some combination of technology / low-cost brokerages to take over a lot of the business, while some demographics of buyers / sellers or types of properties will continue to rely on the services of brokers who will be forced to up their game in order to compete. I fully expect a bloodbath among some of the larger national / international brokerages, as many of them have abusive, unsustainable business models.
I had a neighbor once tell me how much they loved their agent, and before I could stop myself I blurted out "I can't believe they stayed sober long enough to get your deal done!" It's a sad reality that while agents get to know who is trustworthy / skilled, because we deal with each other every day, the public seldom really gets the whole picture. I think it's worse in large metro areas because there are thousands of agents - so doing your research is hard. I assure you - national brands have very little to do with quality either.
If I'm being really crass - I find a lot of people pick their agents like it is a beauty contest. They pick based on age, looks, they go to the same church we do, our kids are at the same school, etc. And for a lot of people, whether they feel good about the agent has more to do with if they are now "friends" then if there was actually a successful business outcome.
My best advise is to treat a real estate agent the same way you might your accountant / lawyer / financial planner / private banker: don't just pick one off Zillow or at random, but carefully cultivate a relationship before you need their services and take steps to discern for yourself whether they are acting as a fiduciary. I agree completely - there are a lot of bad actors in this space, but over the next decade I expect market forces to drive a lot of people out of the business and improve the professional standard.