Re:Python does support if-else in lambdas...
by thomasmallen on Sunday November 09, 2008 @11:26PM
(#358864)
I don't think there's anything wrong with the idiom
Am I behind the times? On a separate note, the code in the examples above is very difficult to read...a lambda really shouldn't be doing if/else operations like these in my opinion.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Python does support if-else in lambdas...
by brianr on Sunday November 09, 2008 @11:39PM
(#358872)
The problem with that construct is that trueaction itself must evaluate to true, or the expression will evaluate to falseaction, which most likely is not what you want:
>>> 0 if 1 else 2
0
>>> 1 and 0 or 2
2
Even crazier things can happen if trueaction has side effects: >>> def trueaction():
... print 'trueaction called'
... return 0
...
>>> def falseaction():
... print 'falseaction called'
... return 'hello'
...
>>> True and trueaction() or falseaction()
trueaction called
falseaction called
'hello'
>>> trueaction() if True else falseaction()
trueaction called
0
Re:Python does support if-else in lambdas...
by myelin on Sunday November 09, 2008 @11:39PM
(#358873)
The danger here is that this will fall through to the falseaction if trueaction returns a false result ("", False, 0, None, [], {}, etc). For example, this will evaluate to "etc":
True and "" or "etc"
So people started doing this instead, as [False] is still 'true' (non-empty lists are 'true' in Python): (condition and [trueaction] or [falseaction])[0]
... which is a bit crufty. So this was added: trueaction if condition else falseaction
Re:Python does support if-else in lambdas...
by thomasmallen on Sunday November 09, 2008 @11:42PM
(#358880)
Ah, that is much better. I've been learning from Dive Into Python which I know is a tad dated, and Pilgrim (sort of) endorses the and...or method.
Re:Python does support if-else in lambdas...
by kaens on Sunday November 09, 2008 @11:51PM
(#358891)
Along with the points other people have made,
trueaction if condition else falseaction
is marginally more clear than condition and trueaction or falseaction
, at least to people who aren't used to seeing and/or used like that. A lot of people, especially newer programmers, aren't used to seeing and...or used for branching that directly.
Re:Python does support if-else in lambdas...
by globalrev on Sunday November 09, 2008 @11:37PM
(#358870)
The formatting got messed up but yes I agree. They were just examples, not the best ones perhaps.
I have felt a need for it sometimes though. Very complicated lambdas are perhaps generally better off as normal functions.
But I hate creating one-time-use functions if it isn't necessary.