News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit: a necessary change in policy by ceol on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:29PM (#3588495)
>Again, why were those illegal and not the examples I gave? "Artistic value" is not a criteria of the Dost test. Why they were posted isn't either.

Probably because the photograph wasn't meant to elicit a sexual response, nor were her genitals the focal point of the photograph.

>If those subreddits were illegal, then so are: many magazines, Wikipedia, Facebook (where a lot of them come), Google (try a search for 'jailbait' images), a huge number of movies, various TV shows and more.

Erm, no. No they're not.

>The only reason you gave (artistic value) is irrelevant to their legality, according to the test.

From the Dost test article:

>>Not all of the criteria need to be met, nor are other criteria necessarily excluded in this test.

>I very much doubt you could tell what most of 11600+ people said.

I could tell the general attitude of the subreddit from the majority of the comments posted. This isn't hard. When you go into /r/trees, you understand they are pro-marijuana. Maybe not all 100% subscribers feel that way, but that doesn't matter. So saying "Well you can't know what all the subscribers think!" is completely meaningless.

>But in any case, if I derive sexual gratification from your posts, do they become obscene?

No.

>I brought them as examples which are relevant to the point being discussed - whether the images are illegal or not.

And taking photos from a child's account and posting them all over the Internet are illegal.

There are no comments on this comment yet.