News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:19AM (#35883606)
How does it help humanity as a whole if nobody is able to capture any value for their work?
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:23AM (#35883622)
What kind of "value" are they capturing?

In my viewpoint, something one makes which can be built upon by another freely and without limit is what helps humanity. I don't want anyone necessarily trying to capture rent-seeking "value" out of their work that cannot be extended by others. That is one reason why I abhor copyright, patents, and intellectual property in general.

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @03:03AM (#35884534)
You cannot extend anyone’s work if you have no food or resources.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @11:47AM (#35889067)
That is an economic argument for something like UBI, not an argument to artificially keep jobs and limit technological progress just so people can make money.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:34PM (#35889751)
All jobs are artificially kept, as would UBI be. They are all artifacts of the law.

Money is a way to allocate resources, and technological progress depends on people having incentives to contribute.

Do you think LLMs are a natural phenomenon?

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:42PM (#35889858)
> technological progress depends on people having incentives to contribute

Does it? That stands in stark contrast to open source in general, where people contribute without any monetary incentives.

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:00PM (#35890119)
> where people contribute without any monetary incentives.

First of all you added in the word ‘monetary’, to straw-man the position.

Secondly, even if we run with your straw-man, I see little evidence this is true. Most successful projects are either corporately funded or begging for corporate funding. You see article after article here bemoaning the lack of funding for open source.

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:35PM (#35890638)
Okay, if we take any incentives in general, that means anything we do is incentivized. Me eating food is incentivized by me not starving to death. It's not a particularly enlightening argument, hence why I preemptively added "monetary," as we were already talking about economic incentives and UBI, but if you want to explain what other incentives you are talking about, please do so, I would want to hear.

In today's world with no UBI, it's no wonder people bemoan the lack of funding, since it's an issue of actually living to produce the OSS one wants to make. If we have something akin to UBI, where we don't force people to stall technological progress in order to satisfy having a job, then this issue would disappear.

And to be clear, I'm also not against corporate funding for OSS, so long as it does remain OSS at the end of the day. Linux has corporate funding yet maintains its OSS status.

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @06:52PM (#35894559)
Earlier you said “people contribute without any monetary incentives”, and now you are admitting that they do need monetary incentives because there is no UBI.

Which is the truth?

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Thursday May 11, 2023 @10:09AM (#35902332)
People contribute already without any monetary incentives, but it sure would help to have UBI. I'm not sure what part you're confused about, as it's not an "either/or" proposition.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by nickfromseattle on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:54AM (#35888272)
Is an LLM that slurps up all data created ever, without compensating the creators of that data, and then charges for that access not the definition of "rent seeking"?

Next question, does this share similarities with academic journals that most folks do consider rent seeking organization?

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @11:46AM (#35889055)
I never said that was okay either. LLMs should be open source and open data. Yes, this viewpoint shares similarities with academic journals that also rent seek.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:31PM (#35889717)
How do you propose that LLMs are paid for?
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:40PM (#35889838)
Through government funds, as other public works projects are. Or if people want to privately create their own, they can do so, as long as the results are open.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:58PM (#35890071)
Why should just LLMs be funded that way and not all software?
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:28PM (#35890532)
You're right, all software should be funded that way.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:40PM (#35890697)
Who would decide what to fund?
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:54PM (#35890879)
How are public works projects funded now? Same way. And if corporations want to fund certain projects too, they can. It's simple, extrapolate how we fund current projects and do the same with software, it's not that complicated.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @05:56PM (#35894043)
Earlier you said:

> In my viewpoint, something one makes which can be built upon by another freely and without limit is what helps humanity.

Now you are saying that LLMs, and maybe even all software, should only be funded by the approval of appointed government committees.

Do you not see the contradiction in your viewpoint?

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @06:19PM (#35894263)
Did you miss the parts where I mentioned that private individuals and corporations can also fund their own software, as we do today? My point is that as long as code, models, and data are open source, we will be free to mix and match and improve upon them, instead of only having rich corporations hold them. One way to do so is to have the government fund projects and open source them, as an alternative to corporate closed source control.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @06:49PM (#35894527)
> Did you miss the parts where I mentioned that private individuals and corporations can also fund their own software, as we do today?

You aren’t being honest.

Today we’re allowed to fund our own software and use it as we please for private purposes or to license it to others. Today there is no law forcing us to give it away.

This isn’t what you are proposing.

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Thursday May 11, 2023 @10:12AM (#35902372)
How am I not being honest? If you misunderstand or don't read my words as they are written, that's not really my problem.

How do you know what I'm proposing? Perhaps we should have a law forcing software to be open source.

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by nickfromseattle on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @12:59PM (#35890107)
Thank you for the interesting discussion!

> I never said that was okay either. LLMs should be open source and open data.

> That is one reason why I abhor copyright, patents, and intellectual property in general.

If it turns out that closed-source LLMs become the most valuable companies in the world, any thoughts on how to align / reconcile your ideals around the reality of how the technology has developed in my hypothetical example?

Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by satvikpendem on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @01:30PM (#35890567)
There are multiple gradations of value. Linux exists even as Windows and macOS does also. They each have different strengths and weaknesses. It could be the case that only closed source LLMs are the most prevalent, but we have open source LLMs already available today that run on device and for free essentially. I don't necessarily see the world only moving towards closed source LLMs.
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by casey2 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @04:44AM (#35885156)
Does "work" here mean buying rights to books? And since Pearson aren't paying their fair share, why should the public do the work of holding a trial?
Re:Pearson taking legal action over use of its textbooks to ... by throw74774 on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @10:05AM (#35887560)
What do you mean they aren’t paying their fair share? You just said they bought the rights.

Also it seems like you are saying we should just pre-judge cases without using the courts. Basically just end the rule of law. Not sure that’s a good plan.