Re:Tucker Carlson bringing show to Twitter
by theturtletalks on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:54PM
(#35882705)
Has the line between mention and promotion been tested? I remember hearing about some cases where the former seemed likely, but the latter was argued. I could be mistaken though.
Re:Tucker Carlson bringing show to Twitter
by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:15PM
(#35882843)
> Has the line between mention and promotion been tested?
Wikipedia lists some specific cases with regard to symbols where it has, but more generally its pretty clear that Germany has not made any effort to prohibit mention of Nazis [0], even while they prohibit Nazi (and other “unconstitutional and terrorist group”) propaganda.
Re:Tucker Carlson bringing show to Twitter
by theturtletalks on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:01PM
(#35883165)
In this case, Germany is given the benefit of the doubt. In general, do you think tolerating intolerance is right? Another example would be movie studios removing the twin towers from movies and shows just so the "terrorist don't win"? Is that right?
AFAIK, German law does not forbid “any mention of Nazism”, it forbids “Dissemination of propaganda material of unconstitutional and terrorist organisations” and “Use of symbols of unconstitutional and terrorist organisations” including, but very much not limited to, the propaganda and symbols of the Nazi Party. But this does not – for instance, as controversies in 00s established, prohibit incorporation of Nazi symbols in contexts that, taken as a whole, are directed against them. The issue isn’t mention but promotion of Nazism, etc.