News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Devil Mode: A twisted key sequence translator for modifie... by brokenkebaby on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:57PM (#35879615)
Now, it's clearer what you mean. But still doesn't not make much sense, sorry! You apparently see something which I didn't say, and refute something which I didn't say with impressive energy. No, making docs using common terms of today won't make you wish to turn Emacs to Visual Studio, or whatever other IDE you don't like. There are Emacs tutorials written in languages other than English where standard terminology for that particular language used. You know, you would not invent a separate word just to mirror idiosyncrasy of Emacs slang present in English. Trust me, there are no signs that after reading them somebody got obsessed with turning Emacs into Visual Studio.
Re:Devil Mode: A twisted key sequence translator for modifie... by _a_a_a_ on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @05:05PM (#35880392)
Then you destroy any remaining trace of a link between the key binding and the action. You can imagine the conversation

"control p to go up? Control y to paste? v to go down – perhaps that's v for vertically down or something? Who designed this crap anyway".

Maybe it would work but I'm not feeling optimistic :-)

Re:Devil Mode: A twisted key sequence translator for modifie... by brokenkebaby on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @04:26AM (#35885041)
Emacs is a programmable environment constructor, ain't it? Significant share of users prefer evil-mode, and use "p in command mode", not c-y. There are people who have custom keyboards (and even pedals) and their bindings often tuned to that fact. So "control y" is not more sacred than the leftmost pedal, and link is ephemeral anyway.
Re:Devil Mode: A twisted key sequence translator for modifie... by _a_a_a_ on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @06:48AM (#35885726)
I think the mnemonic link matters for beginners, but let's say I agree with you. By calling the link ephemeral haven't you just undermined your own argument that the terminology is a barrier?
Re:Devil Mode: A twisted key sequence translator for modifie... by brokenkebaby on Thursday May 11, 2023 @04:27AM (#35899392)
Of course I haven't as I made zero claim about mnemonics. We're talking about readability i.e. cognitive burden which by definition increases with amount of unknown words, or words with unexpected contextual meanings