Re:2 Billion Jobs to Disappear by 2030
by mc32 on Monday February 13, 2012 @06:55PM
(#3587921)
One of the main issues to me is that these things keep getting imagined in a vacuum, a place where logic reigns and technology as as perfect as its imagined.
For example this:
>Neighborhoods will be designed differently and all City planning departments will have to rethink their jobs.
This is not much different than today. But, at the same time, you could imagine that sentence to imply vast change. (remind me of the cold reading article the other day)
And:
>One thing I’m not saying is that we will have 2 billion more people unemployed. Rather we will be forced to rethink the whole process of job creation, and we will need to do that very quickly.
How is it that this will be true in 2030 but ALSO happen very quickly?
And:
>Working closely with the inventor community, I’ve had the unusual opportunity to see breakthrough technologies at the formative stages, and there are several around the edges that are now reaching the boiling point.
I mean, it's great to have enthusiasm, but c'mon. We've heard these things over and over --something could finally work out, but the odds are against those techs being the silver bullet in Coal/Petroleum/Nuclear. Lead bullets, yes. But those take many decades.
I mean, optimism is great, but I think he's gone overboard and kind of forgot a bit of skepticsm.
For example this:
>Neighborhoods will be designed differently and all City planning departments will have to rethink their jobs.
This is not much different than today. But, at the same time, you could imagine that sentence to imply vast change. (remind me of the cold reading article the other day)
And:
>One thing I’m not saying is that we will have 2 billion more people unemployed. Rather we will be forced to rethink the whole process of job creation, and we will need to do that very quickly.
How is it that this will be true in 2030 but ALSO happen very quickly?
And:
>Working closely with the inventor community, I’ve had the unusual opportunity to see breakthrough technologies at the formative stages, and there are several around the edges that are now reaching the boiling point.
I mean, it's great to have enthusiasm, but c'mon. We've heard these things over and over --something could finally work out, but the odds are against those techs being the silver bullet in Coal/Petroleum/Nuclear. Lead bullets, yes. But those take many decades.
I mean, optimism is great, but I think he's gone overboard and kind of forgot a bit of skepticsm.