News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by jwwest on Monday February 13, 2012 @06:44PM (#3587878)
I've never understood the enormous popularity of M.G. Siegler. His articles are often published without any attributions or even basic spell checking. Yet somehow he's ridden on the coattails of Apple's ascent by positioning himself among the fandom as a "champion of good taste". In interviews he doesn't even come off as particularly pleasant.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by oldstrangers on Monday February 13, 2012 @06:58PM (#3587933)
Fanboys on either side of the aisle love to pat themselves on the back and reaffirm--almost daily--that yes, they did buy the best product imaginable. It's the same reason Gruber makes half a million a year writing snarky one liners.

Some sort of subconscious need to find superiority in consumer purchases and brand loyalty. It's kind of disturbing.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by amartya916 on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:27PM (#3588017)
While there is some truth to what you said, I don't think dragging John Gruber is appropriate. One can at least see that a post is well written (I actually think that in terms of plain English, Gruber does the best job within the tech. blogosphere) and that some care and thought has been put into framing a cogent argument. From there, it's up to you to agree or disagree. I am not referring to the links he posts, but the actual writing that he does.

MG Siegler on the other hand has been perfectly described by Lyons. All he does is generate venom, and copious amounts of it, followed by a couple of "Fuck You's"" and so-on. I think he's the National Enquirer of tech. reporting. And hence, ankle biting Chihuahua is more than correct.

If Dan's reading this, good-luck mate. I am glad you called out Siegler's bluff. What he was trying to do with the Path issue was simply 'diversion'. Rake up an issue that can get people talking - loud enough - that it drowns out the issue at hand (callous and selfish handling of privacy in the Silicon Valley).

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by chalst on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @09:23AM (#3590050)
Gruber wonders "Lyons has always been an ass, but when did he get so bitter? " and says "Siegler is one of the top writers on the Apple beat, period. Good sources, smart analysis, and he’s been right way way way more often than he’s been wrong."

http://daringfireball.net/2011/08/balls

Gruber and Siegler are symbiotes and it is entirely appropriate to drag Siegler in.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by amartya916 on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @10:07AM (#3590251)
You are right, and Gruber is wrong... in this case. Gruber usually does a good job of citing sources and for the rest of the article he makes some good points. Like I said before, one can agree or disagree. To reiterate though, his rushing to Siegler's defence is just silly. Gruber does himself and his readers a disservice by linking to Siegler's blog. Siegler sensationalizes the smallest of things -something Lyons brings up eloquently- and then is hypocritical enough to try and portray that he actually abhors the practice! The main reason I wanted to not drag Gruber into the discussion was:

a. Lyons' article makes no mention of him. b. Gruber and Siegler might write about Apple, but Gruber can actually write, and Siegler can't. Ankle biting chihuahua is just right.

Anyway, you make a good point, and I hope I clarified why I thought Gruber shouldn't be in this list.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by Steko on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:41PM (#3588235)
The "fanboy dismissal" is here, as usal, a cop out. It's the same copout that 2/3 of the commentariat falls back on whenever the subject comes up of why Apple is so successful. Must be those fanboys, that pixie dust, that RDF...

"Some sort of subconscious need to find superiority in consumer purchases and brand loyalty. It's kind of disturbing."

Or maybe it's just a good blog?

Despite happily not owning a Mac for almost a decade I've continued to read Gruber all this time because his signal to noise ratio is off the charts compared to any other tech blogger. His voice is unique and entertaining. The entire layout is clean and sparse. It's one of the few tech RSS feeds you know isn't going to be knee deep in repackaged press releases and bullshit false equivalence analysis.

If all you had to do to make a half million dollars a year was turn out snarky one liners there'd be a lot more millionaires in the world.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by RyanMcGreal on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @08:09AM (#3589831)
> It's the same copout that 2/3 of the commentariat falls back on whenever the subject comes up of why Apple is so successful. Must be those fanboys, that pixie dust, that RDF...

It's the other way around: Apple isn't successful because of Gruber and Siegler, Gruber and Siegler are successful because they tied their fortunes to Apple.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by asg on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @05:03AM (#3589397)
I don't think this can be construed as 'fanboy dismissal', though the term 'fanboy' itself is controversial.

Post purchase dissonance reduction is a well known cognitive bias[1]. And what can be better for dissonance reduction than someone telling you that you have good taste, and anyone who buys the competition is a philistine?

I should point out that this does not impute anything to the quality of the products themselves. I just posit that blogs such as Gruber's play a active part in the ecosystem due to our cognitive biases. They are not merely a passive observer.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-purchase_rationalization

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by padobson on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @01:13PM (#3591077)
This might be one of the best comments I've ever read on the web.

These gadgets are EXPENSIVE. If you're clearing $15.00 an hour and you buy a smartphone, that's 15-40 hours of your life that you've dedicated to that little machine. You can see why there would be fervor over those devices, especially for those enthusiasts that have to work so hard to afford them in the first place.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by nowarninglabel on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @02:15AM (#3589009)
Eh, I'll be the counter-point here in that I do own a Mac, love it for the hardware which is amazing, but can't stand Gruber or his ilk. I'm not really sure what draws you to him, but I can tell you just cause I like Mac doesn't mean I want to go find superiority in it or read Gruber's nonsense.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by rkalla on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:29PM (#3588026)
Unfortunately I think it is worse than just justifying your purchase; for a lot of people it is defining their identity.

You say "iPhone's are stupid!" and all they hear is "I think YOU are stupid!".

A lot of people define themselves by distilling the version of themselves they want to portray to the world as a collective of company logos and brands.

I don't think it is healthy, but it sure makes sense why people do it.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by jwwest on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:33PM (#3588037)
This is exactly what Apple set out to do, equate the brand with the self - much like fashion.

Harley Davidson is another example where this occurs.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by roc on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @09:58AM (#3590218)
Even before Apple consciously set out to harness this, people were self-identifying as Unix people, Microsoft people and even CP/M people. So, yes, Apple consciously leverages this. But, no, the behavior is not solely a result of their effort.

Consider all the tribes that don't even have a coherent "brand" behind them: C people and Ruby people; truck people and sports car people; dog people and cat people; PC gamers and console gamers; new york- and chicago-style pizza people; goths and hipsters and rockabillies; nerds and jocks; white-collar and blue-collar people; etc.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by danssig on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @04:18AM (#3589278)
Come on, you think Google doesn't do this? If anything anywhere on the net is critical of something Google does there will an army of fanboys there within seconds in Google's defense.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by tvon on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @11:26AM (#3590582)
If you say "Linux is stupid" or "Ubuntu is stupid" or "FOSS is stupid", you'll get the same response.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by rkalla on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @12:31PM (#3590889)
Oh, I don't think it matters. It just depends on the social circles you run as to what the noun in that sentence is.

You a farmer in Illinois? Then the noun could be "John Deer" or "Monsanto" and you'll get appropriate responses.

If you are a chef in New York you could say "Dilantium Knives" are/aren't stupid and get an appropriate response and so on.

We are a lot like race car drivers anymore; draping the brands of the companies we are proud to identify ourselves by.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by samstave on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:30PM (#3588028)
If you haven't already - watch the documentaries "Century of the self" and "Human Resources" for more disturbing information on how this came to be.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by dpitkin on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:40PM (#3588059)
For a lighter and modern take, the recent BBC show Secrets of the Superbrands does a good job showing why we like what we like. I can also second taking some time to watch "The Century of the Self" but its a bit darker.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by throwaway64 on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:13PM (#3587973)
People fiercely defend their choice to spend a chunk of money on something, otherwise they wasted their money and look foolish, clearly (to themselves) they are not foolish, so they must have spent the money for the right reasons.

The more this perception is challenged, the more fiercely it gets defended. An attack on $BRAND_OF_CHOICE is viewed as an attack on their choice to invest in it, and thus an personal attack on themselves. So they seek to reaffirm their choices via whatever and whoever will say what they want to hear.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognative_dissonance

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by bishnu on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:14PM (#3587978)
Any source for that figure about Gruber's income? I find it hard to believe.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by oldstrangers on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:16PM (#3587987)
Just a rough estimation based off this: http://daringfireball.net/feeds/sponsors/ + Amazon affiliate sales.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by funkah on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @10:54AM (#3590423)
Same old stuff people always say. Gruber, fanboys, yadda yadda, wakka wakka.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by doktrin on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:02PM (#3588122)
Siegler is a shameless bottom feeder. He and his ilk are an embarrassment to the tech community, who have sadly gotten rich off the sweat of others.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by mcantelon on Monday February 13, 2012 @08:46PM (#3588252)
He's a Gruber knockoff. Same religious devotion to Apple, same trollish linkbait.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by recoiledsnake on Monday February 13, 2012 @09:26PM (#3588349)
You forgot the abject Google-hate.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by rjdagost on Monday February 13, 2012 @10:10PM (#3588455)
Siegler falls into the category of "irritainment", entertainment via irritation. He's the type of guy you love to hate and I believe a lot of his popularity stems from that. I can't stand the guy and I think he's completely full of shit. And yet I read almost all of his blog posts.

The only other TechCrunch writer that I regularly read is Devin Coldewey and that's because he has interesting articles and actually seems knowledgeable about technology. In other words I have learned things from his blog posts.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by eaurouge on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @03:24AM (#3589150)
"I can't stand the guy and I think he's completely full of shit."

Then please, stop reading his blog posts, it's the only way he'll learn.

Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by chauzer on Tuesday February 14, 2012 @12:17PM (#3590825)
He's not even entertaining.
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by reuser on Monday February 13, 2012 @06:52PM (#3587907)
Pleasantries aren't part of this kind of "good taste".
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by bluekeybox on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:21PM (#3588004)
Exactly. Whoever said that good taste has anything to do with appearing pleasant?
Re:Hit men, click whores, and paid apologists: Welcome to th... by jwwest on Monday February 13, 2012 @07:36PM (#3588047)
It's hard to imagine someone enjoying his level of celebrity without even trying to appear pleasant. Even Steve Jobs reserved the bulk of his ire for those that worked for him, and appeared caring to his audience (customers), even "patronly".